First Chair Destinations
First Chair Destinations' homes average 4.61 stars across more than 75,000 Airbnb guest reviews in about 80 resort markets across 9 states, seventh on Manager Review's national leaderboard. That overall number hides a consistent problem. In the 52 markets where we can compare it with at least two local competitors, First Chair rates below the local average in 51 of them, and dead last in 37.
What guests say: Guests love the locations: ski-in condos and mountain homes in Steamboat, Breckenridge, Vail, Stowe and Sun Valley. In the lower-rated reviews, the complaints are cold units and no hot water, broken hot tubs and fireplaces, older condos with worn furniture and uncomfortable sofa beds, cleaning that missed the mark, and slow communication.
How it works: First Chair was formed in 2025 by former Vacasa and Wyndham executives, with backing from the private equity firm Paceline Equity Partners. It took over roughly 3,500 of Vacasa's ski and mountain homes after Casago acquired Vacasa, and it operates them under a licensing agreement with Casago. It's headquartered in Steamboat Springs and led by CEO Rishi Nigam. Homes are listed on Airbnb, Vrbo, Booking.com, Casago.com and Vacasa.com. Because the company is so new, many of the reviews behind its ratings were likely written while these homes were still managed by Vacasa.
What it costs: First Chair doesn't publish its commission or contract terms. Its local pages promise no hidden fees and no long-term contracts. Get the rate, every fee and the termination terms in writing before signing.
Watch-outs: First Chair trails local competitors almost everywhere it operates, including its biggest markets. In Breckenridge it's second-to-last of 35 managers (4.62 vs. a local average of 4.79). In Vail it scores 4.67 against 4.79. It's the lowest-rated manager we track in Sun Valley, Silverthorne, Big Sky, Whitefish, Winter Park, Aspen and Stowe. It's closest to its competitors in Jackson, Wyoming and Steamboat Springs. If you're considering First Chair, ask what has changed since it took over from Vacasa, and watch whether its ratings in your market improve.
Best fit: Owners of condos in large ski resorts who want a manager focused only on mountain markets, and who are willing to bet on a new team improving on Vacasa's record.
Verified Homeowner Reviews
Write a reviewRecent guest reviews
Local Rankings
- Reviews of First Chair Destinations in Breckenridge, Colorado
- Reviews of First Chair Destinations in Steamboat Springs, Colorado
- Reviews of First Chair Destinations in Mammoth Lakes, California
- Reviews of First Chair Destinations in Keystone, Colorado
- Reviews of First Chair Destinations in Vail, Colorado
- Reviews of First Chair Destinations in Winter Park, Colorado
- Reviews of First Chair Destinations in Killington, Vermont
- Reviews of First Chair Destinations in Snowmass Village, Colorado
- Reviews of First Chair Destinations in Telluride, Colorado
- Reviews of First Chair Destinations in Durango, Colorado
- Reviews of First Chair Destinations in Big Sky, Montana
- Reviews of First Chair Destinations in Whitefish, Montana
- Reviews of First Chair Destinations in Frisco, Colorado
- Reviews of First Chair Destinations in Stowe, Vermont
- Reviews of First Chair Destinations in Aspen, Colorado
- Reviews of First Chair Destinations in Avon, Colorado
- Reviews of First Chair Destinations in Mountain Village, Colorado
- Reviews of First Chair Destinations in Mccall, Idaho
- Reviews of First Chair Destinations in Beaver Creek, Colorado
- Reviews of First Chair Destinations in Crested Butte, Colorado
- Reviews of First Chair Destinations in Ludlow, Vermont
- Reviews of First Chair Destinations in Jackson, Wyoming
- Reviews of First Chair Destinations in Teton Village, Wyoming
- Reviews of First Chair Destinations in Pagosa Springs, Colorado
- Reviews of First Chair Destinations in Silverthorne, Colorado
- Reviews of First Chair Destinations in Newry, Maine
- Reviews of First Chair Destinations in Fraser, Colorado
- Reviews of First Chair Destinations in Sun Valley, Idaho
- Reviews of First Chair Destinations in Copper Mountain, Colorado
- Reviews of First Chair Destinations in Wilson, Wyoming
- Reviews of First Chair Destinations in Ketchum, Idaho
- Reviews of First Chair Destinations in Dillon, Colorado
- Reviews of First Chair Destinations in Warren, Vermont
- Reviews of First Chair Destinations in South Fork, Colorado
- Reviews of First Chair Destinations in Hartford, Vermont
- Reviews of First Chair Destinations in York, Maine
- Reviews of First Chair Destinations in Sandpoint, Idaho
- Reviews of First Chair Destinations in Wells, Maine
- Reviews of First Chair Destinations in Granby, Colorado
- Reviews of First Chair Destinations in Lincoln, New Hampshire
- Reviews of First Chair Destinations in Grand Lake, Colorado
- Reviews of First Chair Destinations in Bethel, Maine
- Reviews of First Chair Destinations in Bigfork, Montana
- Reviews of First Chair Destinations in Old Orchard Beach, Maine
- Reviews of First Chair Destinations in Conway, New Hampshire
- Reviews of First Chair Destinations in Dover, Vermont
- Reviews of First Chair Destinations in Columbia Falls, Montana
- Reviews of First Chair Destinations in Fairplay, Colorado
- Reviews of First Chair Destinations in Bartlett, New Hampshire
- Reviews of First Chair Destinations in Edwards, Colorado
- Reviews of First Chair Destinations in Kennebunk, Maine
- Reviews of First Chair Destinations in Hampton, New Hampshire
- Reviews of First Chair Destinations in Ogunquit, Maine
- Reviews of First Chair Destinations in Kalispell, Montana
- Reviews of First Chair Destinations in Portland, Maine
- Reviews of First Chair Destinations in Gloucester, Massachusetts
- Reviews of First Chair Destinations in Rockport, Massachusetts
- Reviews of First Chair Destinations in Sagle, Idaho
- Reviews of First Chair Destinations in Waitsfield, Vermont
- Reviews of First Chair Destinations in Wilmington, Vermont
- Reviews of First Chair Destinations in Stratton, Vermont
- Reviews of First Chair Destinations in Waterville Valley, New Hampshire
- Reviews of First Chair Destinations in Tabernash, Colorado
- Reviews of First Chair Destinations in Dover, Idaho
- Reviews of First Chair Destinations in Jackson, New Hampshire
- Reviews of First Chair Destinations in Bridgton, Maine
- Reviews of First Chair Destinations in Franconia, New Hampshire
- Reviews of First Chair Destinations in Colchester, Vermont
- Reviews of First Chair Destinations in Cavendish, Vermont
- Reviews of First Chair Destinations in Lakeside, Montana
- Reviews of First Chair Destinations in Jay, Vermont
- Reviews of First Chair Destinations in Hailey, Idaho
- Reviews of First Chair Destinations in Madison, New Hampshire
- Reviews of First Chair Destinations in Castleton, Vermont
- Reviews of First Chair Destinations in Plymouth, Vermont
- Reviews of First Chair Destinations in Ossipee, New Hampshire
- Reviews of First Chair Destinations in North Hero, Vermont
- Reviews of First Chair Destinations in Wardsboro, Vermont