Manager Review

First Chair Destinations reviews in Pagosa Springs, Colorado

First Chair Destinations holds a 4.68 guest rating in Pagosa Springs, Colorado, computed from 896 Airbnb guest reviews across the vacation rentals they manage there. That ranks them 7 of 7 managers in the market on guest satisfaction. See the top ranked vacation rental managers in Pagosa Springs, or homeowner reviews of First Chair Destinations on their profile.

First Chair Destinations's guest rating in Pagosa Springs, Colorado of 4.68 is below average and may adversely impact performance. Some of this can come from specific properties they manage — but where reviews point to manager weaknesses (responsiveness, cleanliness, listing accuracy) that would apply to your home too, they can adversely affect your bookings and the quality of guests you attract. You can see higher-rated managers in Pagosa Springs.

Recent guest reviews in Pagosa Springs

BlakeOctober 2026
“Beautiful Airbnb in a nice location. Overall, we had a fairly good experience but the communication was kinda weird: I got a text from someone saying they were the property manager but I didn't get any heads up via the app so when I verified that I wasn't getting spam and tried to get more info, the comms on the app (seemed like AI) just sent me back to the text. I had to copy/paste the conversation via text into the app so I'd be covered by Airbnb consumer protections. The comms were also lacking important details and I had to message back a lot to get clarity. Apart from the annoyances with the comms, it was an overall good experience”
airbnb
MarkOctober 2026
“Starting with the negative, outside grill only works on two of the burners, TV is difficult to operate being slow in response and volume fluctuates, you have mice, soap door in the dishwasher does not stay shut and you want us wash dishes before we leave but only one dishwasher soap pack. Positive, love the deck especially in the morning with coffee and after getting home to sit and unwind, very homey environment, enjoy seeing the deer in the yard.”
airbnb
Tawny And CorySeptember 2026
“Lots of space. Nice decor. Beds clean and comfortable. First night was rough as a high pitched alarm was going off that we couldn’t locate in the master bedroom & ended up missing several hours of sleep. There was also a smoky/something is hot smell in the room. Local mgmt was not responding so had to message through Airbnb & someone called right away. Eventually maintenance found the problem—a water alarm in the crawl space because the sump pump was not working. He was able to get the alarm off. Then we listened to the sump pump for the rest of the time because it was raining the whole visit. Cleaning was not great. The floors appeared to not be vacuumed with visible debris on the area rug in living room, a lack of vacuum markings in the thick green carpeting upstairs, and we also found multiple shards of glass on the tile floor in the kitchen. Ceiling fans too dusty to use. Great to have garage access in all the rainy weather. Overall nice place with some cleaning needs.”
airbnb