Manager Review

Properties by Preston in Ohio

Properties by Preston's guest reviews across Ohio. See homeowner reviews of Properties by Preston on their profile.

Properties by Preston's guest rating in Ohio of 4.05 is below average and may adversely impact performance. Some of this can come from specific properties they manage — but where reviews point to manager weaknesses (responsiveness, cleanliness, listing accuracy) that would apply to your home too, they can adversely affect your bookings and the quality of guests you attract. You can see higher-rated managers in Ohio.

Recent guest reviews

AvionaMay 2026Parma
DO NOT BOOK THIS PLACE ! THEY ARE SCAMMING ! Upon arrivals someone else was living in the apartment. There was food , nice, and weed on the tables. The building is falling apart. When we contacted Preston they tried to tell us we weren’t inside the correct unit, however we used our correct door code to get in. They were refusing to give us our money, they wouldn’t call us. We had to threaten to call the police in order to get our reservation cancelled and our full refund. The reviews on this property are FAKE !!! they continue to allow people to book this place, still their money, and someone else is living there the entire time.
airbnb
PedroMay 2026Columbus
Good place to stay, host is very respectful, we will stay with them again
airbnb
LeeAnnApril 2026Columbus
Stayed here from Jan to April for my last clinical of Grad school. The apt was fine for my needs since I wasn’t there much due to the long clinical hours. I had expected to head home on 4/3 but they added a half clinical day. I contacted the host as soon as I knew this asking to get an additional 2 hours to check out. Was told they couldn’t guarantee that and to contact them again the night before-which I did and got the same answer we can’t guarantee a late checkout-check with us in the morning. I had an early AM start since it was a half day and couldn’t wait for an answer. However, they were willing for me to pay for an extra night instead of granting a late check out-which doesn’t make sense. Students don’t get paid for clinical. This host was not willing to work with me asking for an extra 2 hours. I will not recommend this host to other students and request this host be removed from the University’s list. I have never had an issue with any other host like this.
airbnb
DariellMarch 2026Parma
The unit had sh*t stains on and in the toilet, the bathtub was very dirty there was crumbs over the kitchen floor I had to go buy cleaning supplies because there was none available. I ended up leaving due to the uncleanliness which led me to get sick and the host was very unhelpful and did not give me a refund for the remainder of my trip. The only pro was that the place was spacey.
airbnb
DanaFebruary 2026Parma
It’s a one bedroom apartment, bed is comfortable and the folks that run the Airbnb are very fast in response to my questions.
airbnb

Amongst managers in Ohio, Properties by Preston currently ranks 18/18 on guest satisfaction. See the top ranked vacation rental managers in Ohio.