Manager Review

Simply Kelleys Resort reviews in Kelleys Island, Ohio

4.81

Simply Kelleys Resort holds a 4.81 guest rating in Kelleys Island, Ohio, computed from 31 guest reviews across the vacation rentals they manage there. That ranks them 1 of 2 managers in the market on guest satisfaction. See the top ranked vacation rental managers in Kelleys Island, or homeowner reviews of Simply Kelleys Resort on their profile.

Recent guest reviews in Kelleys Island

CarterAugust 2026
“Place was great! It was clean and was a nice place for a quick weekend stay. Also nicely priced! We loved it, will definitely come back!”
airbnb
SaraAugust 2026
“The first-floor unit was ok, the bathroom sink and kitchenette sink are high, so hard to use. The shower is not suitable for anyone taller than 5'4". The curtain panels for the French doors do not completely cover the enter door, so there is gap. Given the unit is on the first floor, anyone walking by can see into the unit. The deadbolt lock was present but did not work. The entrance door electronic locking system was sketchy. I was not confident with the lock. I relied on the lock on the screen door. The mattresses were less than average quality.”
airbnb
GregAugust 2026
“Incredible locations. Great restaurant next door - food and drinks were fantastic. Easy walk to uptown.”
airbnb
EmilyAugust 2026
“This is such a great location to be! We really enjoyed the deck overlooking the water. We brought our dogs and it was a great spot to put their tie down. You are located right across from The Villa restaurant which had live music playing all afternoon on Saturday. We didn't mind because it made it enjoyable for us as we hung out while our toddler luckily slept like a rock during his nap, but something to note. Great walkability to restaurants too!”
airbnb
JanAugust 2026
“Great Lake view and 15 minute walk to downtown.”
airbnb