Manager Review

First Choice Lodging Company in Ohio

First Choice Lodging Company's guest reviews across Ohio. See homeowner reviews of First Choice Lodging Company on their profile.

First Choice Lodging Company's guest rating in Ohio of 4.59 is below average and may adversely impact performance. Some of this can come from specific properties they manage — but where reviews point to manager weaknesses (responsiveness, cleanliness, listing accuracy) that would apply to your home too, they can adversely affect your bookings and the quality of guests you attract. You can see higher-rated managers in Ohio.

Recent guest reviews

TobiAugust 2026Albany
Sadly, our family does NOT recommend this cabin and we will not return. Our kids were excited for the pool, but when we arrived it was green, smelled bad, and was not something we felt comfortable letting them swim in. We were told it was “safe,” but it wasn’t cleaned until the next day, costing us a day of enjoying something we paid for. There were also many other issues: a rotten-smelling dishwasher, no locks on bathroom doors, a dirty master bathroom, broken microwave, hot tub jets not working properly, poor insulation where you can hear everything, uncomfortable spring beds, missing closet doors, and a wasp nest on the porch that resulted in someone getting stung. We’ve stayed in many cabins and have never experienced this many maintenance and cleanliness issues. For the price, we expected much better. We cannot recommend this cabin and suggest reading the reviews carefully before booking.
airbnb
MasoodAugust 2026Albany
The place was amazing. Really enjoyed. But it was raining both days so couldn't really enjoy outdoors.
airbnb
CrystalJuly 2026Albany
Both houses are nice, the outdoors was so peaceful and beautiful!
airbnb
TammyJuly 2026Albany
Nice place to hold large families, the kids enjoyed swings and monkey bars. Had a very nice time.
airbnb
MarissaJuly 2026Albany
I liked the house itself and it was suitable for our needs, except they advertised that it has central AC when it does not. They only have window units in the bedrooms. And on our last day as we were cleaning, we saw mold in the units. They communicated well until we had issues then they were slow to respond and didn’t do anything about our problems.
airbnb

Amongst managers in Ohio, First Choice Lodging Company currently ranks 20/22 on guest satisfaction. See the top ranked vacation rental managers in Ohio.