Manager Review

The Cottages on the Key

Verified Homeowner Reviews

Write a review

No homeowner reviews yet — be the first to review The Cottages on the Key.

Recent guest reviews

MikeOctober 2026Siesta Key, Florida
“We had an awesome stay, one of our best ever Airbnb experiences. The home was more than expected, the property manager was friendly and responsive, and the location can't be beat. We loved every moment of our stay, highly recommend!”
airbnb
BillyOctober 2026Anna Maria, Florida
“Great stay for our 3 families with teens over school break. Host communicated well.”
airbnb
IsaiahOctober 2026Siesta Key, Florida
“We had a wonderful family trip. Plenty of room and the location was unbeatable… highly recommend. Hosts were immediately responsive to any need. A++”
airbnb
PatriciaSeptember 2026Siesta Key, Florida
“I decided on a "staycation" for a few nights, and this place totally fit the bill. I stayed upstairs in a 1 bed/1 bath. I did ask for an early check-in, and they were very responsive and accommodating. The bed was so comfortable. TV had a lot of great channels. The kitchen was perfect for my needs with anything needed for cook up a great meal. The complimentary cupcakes in the fridge were so nice. There were even fresh ice cubes in the freeze, nice touch! Unfortunately, the coffee maker didn't work but I communicated this to the host, and they were quick to respond. The only thing that might have been helpful is if there was a dishwasher but not a big deal for me. The grounds and outdoor furniture were beautiful and the pool was perfect. So close to everything, restaurants, tiki bars, shops and most important the beach! I have stayed at many places in the village, but this was my first time here. I will definitely be back in the future.”
airbnb
AlanSeptember 2026Siesta Key, Florida
“We really liked staying at the house it was just like the pictures on line location was great a quick walk to Siesta Key beach and a short drive to Siesta Village. Best thing about the house is spend 3-5 hours at the beach then come back and spend time in the pool. Bedrooms were perfect for our family and having 3 full bathrooms was excellent, also having a washer and dryer at the house really helped with having a 2 year old granddaughter with us. If your thinking of renting a home in Siesta Key I highly recommend Cottages On The Key you won’t be disappointed”
airbnb
SydneySeptember 2026Sarasota, Florida
“Wonderful location the house were incredibly responsive and accommodating to all of our request. The house was very clean and had everything we needed and was absolutely beautiful. Exactly has explained would definitely stay again.”
airbnb
MarySeptember 2026Anna Maria, Florida
“Amazing home! Lots of space to spread out. Responsive hosts. Welcome cupcakes and the high end toiletries in each bathroom were a special touch and added to the upscale feel of the house.”
airbnb
MeaghanSeptember 2026Anna Maria, Florida
“The entire Cottage Crew was amazing to work with from start to finish! From the moment we checked in until we checked out we enjoyed The Salty Sister to its entirety. From the AMAZING location, the wonderful kitchen, the backyard pool, the peaceful front patio, and the ocean view. We couldn’t have found a better place to relax, recharge and escape our everyday lives. On our 1st night we ordered Chinese and one of the Fortune Cookies said "A lifetime of precious moments with loved ones is coming" We couldn’t have summed up the week better than that! It was a week filled with laughs, blessings, sunrises and sunsets, sunshine, toes in the sand, and front porch sitting! We cant wait for next year!”
airbnb
AndreSeptember 2026Siesta Key, Florida
“This was one of our favorite homes from our trip! The house is beautiful, spacious, and full of thoughtful details. The pool area was a highlight: the water stayed pleasantly warm, and the spa with its waterfall was spectacular. We also appreciated the toiletry kits in each bathroom, the plentiful towels, and the comfortable linens.” “The layout worked wonderfully for our group, with four bedrooms upstairs and a game room downstairs near the pool and patio. The hosts were so kind and responsive, and they even allowed us to check out very late, which we really appreciated.” “We loved the house, the location, and the hospitality. We would happily stay again!””
airbnb
AlfredoSeptember 2026Sarasota, Florida
“A beautiful property, very close to the beach. I recommend it 100%, and we are thinking of returning in the future. We really appreciated the cupcakes that welcomed us.”
airbnb

Local Rankings