Manager Review

The Cottages on the Key in Sarasota, Florida

4.87

This is the local review page for The Cottages on the Key in Sarasota, Florida. Amongst managers in Sarasota, The Cottages on the Key currently ranks 4 of 21 on guest satisfaction. See the top ranked vacation rental managers in Sarasota, or see homeowner reviews of The Cottages on the Key on their profile.

Recent guest reviews

SusanJune 2026
We had 3 separate multi generational families staying for a week and we all felt like we had our “own space”. The pool and back yard felt private and the entire place was spotless and well stocked. The beach was just a quick walk and it was conveniently located to other amenities. The host was friendly and quickly responsive with any questions. They made our stay as smooth and easy as possible.
airbnb
OlgaJune 2026
We had an amazing stay! The home was perfectly located just one block from St Armands Circle making it easy to walk to shops and restaurants. We were greeted with delicious cupcakes in the refrigerator waiting for us after our long drive in. The home was beautifully decorated and the beds were very comfortable. We all enjoyed the pool after long hot days. Highly recommend!
airbnb
AnnJune 2026
Our stay with 2 of our families was superb. The home is spacious, with room for everyone. It has everything you need. We enjoyed the pool, the multiple decks, jetted tub and massive island for eating and gathering. The location and walk to the beach is perfect. The booking, communication and check out was flawless. Highly recommend The Cottages On The Key’s and this listing.
airbnb
JenniferJune 2026
We had a wonderful visit! The beach is so easy to walk to, as well as restaurants. They have an umbrella, chairs, boogie boards and wagon to make things very convenient. The pool was wonderful and a lot of fun for our mixed age crew of adults, teens, and a toddler. We had a water pressure issue that they fixed quickly. Very responsive and friendly. We’re already talking about making a return trip next year!
airbnb
JamesJune 2026
Great location close to the beach, very clean, kids had fun in the pool, comfortable and convenient for seven of us. Company was extremely responsive.
airbnb