Manager Review

The Cottages on the Key reviews in Sarasota, Florida

4.89

The Cottages on the Key holds a 4.89 guest rating in Sarasota, Florida, computed from 324 Airbnb guest reviews across the vacation rentals they manage there. That ranks them 5 of 28 managers in the market on guest satisfaction. See the top ranked vacation rental managers in Sarasota, or homeowner reviews of The Cottages on the Key on their profile.

Recent guest reviews in Sarasota

SydneySeptember 2026
“Wonderful location the house were incredibly responsive and accommodating to all of our request. The house was very clean and had everything we needed and was absolutely beautiful. Exactly has explained would definitely stay again.”
airbnb
AlfredoSeptember 2026
“A beautiful property, very close to the beach. I recommend it 100%, and we are thinking of returning in the future. We really appreciated the cupcakes that welcomed us.”
airbnb
RobertSeptember 2026
“This is a great place and an easy walk to the main Lido Beach. The host was very responsive and accommodating.”
airbnb
AitorSeptember 2026
“Great house in a very nice location. Owner was very approachable and flexible. Excellent communication. Highly appreciated their proactivity.”
airbnb
CarmenSeptember 2026
“The Cottages on the Key is doing a phenomenal job! The unit was immaculate and had everything we needed for our getaway. We were a party of 14 and felt very comfortable throughout our entire stay. The home was spacious, beautifully maintained, and exactly as described. From the moment we arrived, everything was seamless. The house was well stocked, the beds were comfortable, and there was plenty of space for everyone to gather while still having room to spread out. We especially loved the outdoor areas and how easy it was to enjoy everything the beach had to offer. What really stood out was the attention to detail. We were there celebrating my daughter’s 16th birthday and they made it extra special by leaving cupcakes and a birthday surprise for her. The girls had an absolute blast, and we made memories that we will treasure for years to come.”
airbnb