Manager Review

Simple Life Rentals in Sturgeon Bay, Wisconsin

4.78

This is the local review page for Simple Life Rentals in Sturgeon Bay, Wisconsin. See homeowner reviews of Simple Life Rentals on their profile.

Simple Life Rentals's guest rating in Sturgeon Bay, Wisconsin of 4.78 is below average and may adversely impact performance. Some of this can come from specific properties they manage — but where reviews point to manager weaknesses (responsiveness, cleanliness, listing accuracy) that would apply to your home too, they can adversely affect your bookings and the quality of guests you attract. You can see higher-rated managers in Sturgeon Bay.

Recent guest reviews

KirylJune 2026
nice quiet retreat in the woods close to the cave point and dunes park. 20-25 min drive to West Coast towns
airbnb
JenJune 2026
New construction. Quiet. Comfortable beds. Good water pressure. Well stocked kitchen. Tons of mosquitoes and 5+ mosquitoes would literally hitch rides on your clothing into the house! They were relentless. Couldn’t enjoy the beach without being attacked. It was insane, so we mostly hung out inside or went to the local towns. 2 smoke detector batteries were low and linked, so at 2am ALL of the smoke detectors went off. Found the trash bins in the woods near the street, after looking for them under the deck, as instructed. They have some kinks to work out, but all in all, it was a good stay.
airbnb
MaggieJune 2026
We had a wonderful stay. surrounded by tall evergreens and beautiful sunsets. The home was a well kept up and a true old family home atmosphere. Glorious ! I would rent again.
airbnb
MeganMay 2026
We had a wonderful stay and would absolutely return. The location right on the lake is hard to beat—the views were beautiful, and we loved being able to walk the beach for miles each day. The outdoor spaces were especially enjoyable, with a comfortable deck, plenty of seating, and a pristine grill that we ended up using every day. The fenced-in yard was perfect for our dogs and gave us great peace of mind while they explored and relaxed. The hosts went above and beyond with an incredibly generous gift basket filled with local treats, and we were pleasantly surprised to find neoprene suits available for guests to use in the lake. The home itself was spacious, comfortable, and thoughtfully stocked with everything we needed. This was exactly the kind of place we were looking for—a peaceful retreat where we could relax, recharge, and enjoy the beauty of the lake. Highly recommended!
airbnb
KellyMay 2026
Such a wonderful getaway! The apartment was quaint, cozy, and had everything we needed for a relaxing stay. It was the perfect home base for touring the neighboring bays, and we loved coming back after a day of exploring. Great location, peaceful atmosphere, and a charming touch throughout. Would absolutely stay here again!
airbnb