Manager Review

Simple Life Rentals reviews in Sister Bay, Wisconsin

4.71

Simple Life Rentals holds a 4.71 guest rating in Sister Bay, Wisconsin, computed from 298 Airbnb guest reviews across the vacation rentals they manage there. That ranks them 3 of 3 managers in the market on guest satisfaction. See the top ranked vacation rental managers in Sister Bay, or homeowner reviews of Simple Life Rentals on their profile.

Simple Life Rentals's guest rating in Sister Bay, Wisconsin of 4.71 is below average and may adversely impact performance. Some of this can come from specific properties they manage — but where reviews point to manager weaknesses (responsiveness, cleanliness, listing accuracy) that would apply to your home too, they can adversely affect your bookings and the quality of guests you attract. You can see higher-rated managers in Sister Bay.

Recent guest reviews in Sister Bay

ChelseaOctober 2026
“This was one of the nicest Airbnbs I have stayed in, it was in a great quiet and private location, was super clean, remodel made it seem brand new, and had just about everything we needed! Would stay again in a heartbeat.”
airbnb
RaySeptember 2026
“Lovely remodeled space 5 min walk from Main Street and the lakeshore. I wanted to take home the mattress and the linens. Wonderful! Super comfortable space with a quiet back yard. Perfect if you have a pet to let out or just for private coffee or glass of wine. Chop steakhouse for the filet! You won’t be disappointed. Ray”
airbnb
JohnSeptember 2026
“We had a lovely stay by lake Michigan! The location by the lake is absolutely stunning and we absolutely loved being able to sit by the fire put and look up at the stars!”
airbnb
PaulSeptember 2026
“A comfortable stay. A lovely water view, but no actual water access. The channel for boat parking is in the small slot adjacent to the larger channel shown in the pictures, and thus difficult to get on/off a boat here. It’s a peaceful location with a pleasant short walk to an excellent beach. The beach felt undiscovered, despite a holiday weekend. The cottage is a bit dated and expensive. That being said, I would recommend it.”
airbnb
AllisonAugust 2026
“Beautiful, peaceful location! Thoroughly enjoyed the pier, the fire pit, and the swing looking over the water! The home was stocked with everything we could have needed and also had many books, magazines, and games. Only complaints were that it was slightly damp inside (likely due to lack of central AC during late summer). But hey, that’s lake life I guess!”
airbnb