Manager Review

Simple Life Rentals in Sister Bay, Wisconsin

4.71

This is the local review page for Simple Life Rentals in Sister Bay, Wisconsin. See homeowner reviews of Simple Life Rentals on their profile.

Simple Life Rentals's guest rating in Sister Bay, Wisconsin of 4.71 is below average and may adversely impact performance. Some of this can come from specific properties they manage — but where reviews point to manager weaknesses (responsiveness, cleanliness, listing accuracy) that would apply to your home too, they can adversely affect your bookings and the quality of guests you attract. You can see higher-rated managers in Sister Bay.

Recent guest reviews

BetsyJune 2026
The house was clean upon arrival & ready on time, which we appreciated. Unfortunately, several issues significantly impacted our stay. The garbage disposal was broken upon arrival. I was told a repair person would come, but they never showed due to a "family emergency"; the issue remained unresolved during our stay. The biggest disappointment was the exterior of the property. The listing advertised a large outdoor seating area, but was unusable. The yard was overgrown with weeds, the outdoor cushions were dirty & stained, & there were extensive cobwebs throughout the seating area. It obviously had not been cleaned for the season. We contacted management multiple times. Instead of any assistance, we received AI responses expressing regret for our dissatisfaction & stating that the matter would be addressed internally. No action was taken during our stay & no practical solution was offered. We were not able to dine outside at all. High price for a house I would not use again.
airbnb
PiyaJune 2026
We had a great time in this house. Nice lakefront location. Main strip and shops is a drive away and cell service isn’t great. Wifi in house worked pretty well, minor issues. Beds were comfortable and shower had great pressure. Overall we had a great stay!
airbnb
TiaJune 2026
This house fit lots of people and the fenced in backyard was great. Although it is right on a busy road, the home feels secluded. Communications were slow when wifi went out and considering it was wedding morning, that was a bit frustrating, but it was overall a fun place to stay at and everyone really enjoyed themselves.
airbnb
LoganJune 2026
a
airbnb
SusanMay 2026
Another great year at Waters End Cottage! Love the view of the lake!
airbnb