Manager Review

Rent Door County reviews in Sister Bay, Wisconsin

4.74

Rent Door County holds a 4.74 guest rating in Sister Bay, Wisconsin, computed from 295 Airbnb guest reviews across the vacation rentals they manage there. That ranks them 2 of 3 managers in the market on guest satisfaction. See the top ranked vacation rental managers in Sister Bay, or homeowner reviews of Rent Door County on their profile.

Rent Door County's guest rating in Sister Bay, Wisconsin of 4.74 is below average and may adversely impact performance. Some of this can come from specific properties they manage — but where reviews point to manager weaknesses (responsiveness, cleanliness, listing accuracy) that would apply to your home too, they can adversely affect your bookings and the quality of guests you attract. You can see higher-rated managers in Sister Bay.

Recent guest reviews in Sister Bay

SophieOctober 2026
“We had a great stay! The location was PERFECT - being able to walk to everywhere in Sister Bay was such a huge plus, especially since parking can be tricky. Check-in and check-out were both super easy, and the rental was comfortable and accessible for everyone. The only small downside was that shampoo, conditioner, and body wash weren't provided, so we had to run out and buy them. Otherwise, it was a great place to stay, and we would definitely recommend it! ESPECIALLY for fall fest that is coming up!”
airbnb
ChristineOctober 2026
“Clean and beautiful home. Perfect location. Highly recommend!”
airbnb
MichaelSeptember 2026
“Very nice location and super easy access to everything. Only thing caught off guard is the size of shower. Other than that everything provided for you that you can think of. Ac units in each room helps keep everyone comfortable and then smart tv makes streaming easy. Ice machine nice for quick ice. Super clean and neat house. Highly recommend.”
airbnb
KelliSeptember 2026
“Photos of this location and home were beautiful, but once we arrived, the home is a little more run down than the photos show and no one must have been there in a long period of time. It smelled closed up and the dead flys/bugs were everywhere as if no one had been there all season. There is a very large branch that is just hanging off one of the trees in front, that could hurt someone. We stayed clear of that part of the yard. Entering information was good and information on the dos and don't was clear. All in all we had a great weekend because we are a group of friends that enjoy each others company no matter where we are. Loved sitting around the outdoor fireplace and reminiscing! Being together and the location (Door County, Lake Michigan View) made the weekend, not the home we stayed in.”
airbnb
MackenzieSeptember 2026
“Great spot in Sister Bay!”
airbnb