Manager Review

Plushy in Hager City, Wisconsin

4.43

This is the local review page for Plushy in Hager City, Wisconsin. Amongst managers in Hager City, Plushy currently ranks 2 of 2 on guest satisfaction. See the top ranked vacation rental managers in Hager City, or see homeowner reviews of Plushy on their profile.

Plushy's guest rating in Hager City, Wisconsin of 4.43 is below average and may adversely impact performance. Some of this can come from specific properties they manage — but where reviews point to manager weaknesses (responsiveness, cleanliness, listing accuracy) that would apply to your home too, they can adversely affect your bookings and the quality of guests you attract. You can see higher-rated managers in Hager City.

Recent guest reviews

RobertMay 2026
“The stay was very good. Lovely neighbors. I never ran into the owner coming in or making noise. It was very private”
airbnb
SamuelMay 2026
“Perfect place for fisherman, plenty or room to park truck and boat, I would stay again.”
airbnb
ChrisApril 2026
“We have stayed here several times when in town for fishing. It has always worked well for us.”
airbnb
PeterMarch 2026
“The owner of this house came over a lot and unannounced. He stayed several days till approximately 10 PM working. He was operating a skid steer at 945 pm one night, tried to pull out a goose neck trailer with his truck at 8pm one day got stuck, rummaging through his garage till late at night, he stands outside and talks to the neighbor till 10 pm. I felt like he came in the house when I was away. There were leaves inside the doorway when I came back, and they weren’t there when I left that morning. There is junk and broke down vehicles all over the back yard, which is not shown in the pics. I would not rent from this owner. Plushy is the property management company which was very helpful in resolving the issues I had. The owner of this house is a different story. DO NOT RENT.”
airbnb
EduardJanuary 2026
“Everything is good, nice house”
airbnb