Manager Review

Simple Life Rentals in Fish Creek, Wisconsin

4.73

This is the local review page for Simple Life Rentals in Fish Creek, Wisconsin. Amongst managers in Fish Creek, Simple Life Rentals currently ranks 3 of 3 on guest satisfaction. See the top ranked vacation rental managers in Fish Creek, or see homeowner reviews of Simple Life Rentals on their profile.

Simple Life Rentals's guest rating in Fish Creek, Wisconsin of 4.73 is below average and may adversely impact performance. Some of this can come from specific properties they manage — but where reviews point to manager weaknesses (responsiveness, cleanliness, listing accuracy) that would apply to your home too, they can adversely affect your bookings and the quality of guests you attract. You can see higher-rated managers in Fish Creek.

Recent guest reviews

AndrewAugust 2026
“Very nice place in a great town”
airbnb
ChristyAugust 2026
“We enjoyed our stay here. The written description does not mention the daybed shown in the pictures. This little farmhouse is cozy. The beds are comfortable and the kitchen is well equipped. The bathroom is a bit tiny and the living room smelled faintly of cigarette smoke. We loved that we could walk into Fish Creek from the rental. It also was very close to the entrance of Peninsula State Park, although you’ll need to drive or rent bikes to explore this because it’s very spread out. Bike rental is within walking distance as are numerous restaurants.”
airbnb
NickyAugust 2026
“This unit is on two floors, bad if you have little or mobility issues, bedding had lots of staining.”
airbnb
AmandaAugust 2026
“As expected and right amount of space for our family of 5!”
airbnb
AngelAugust 2026
“when first arriving with my friends we noticed a puddle of water on the top floor from the leaking A/C window unit and when notifying the Owner I was answered with a Ai response. later my friend steps outside on the Second floor balcony and gets met with a swarm of bees and gets stung 6 times (thankfully not allergic!) and after all that when my other friend tried using the down stairs restroom the sink was clogged and could not be used. Over all a beautiful property that needs some serious maintenance.”
airbnb