Manager Review

Rent Door County reviews in Fish Creek, Wisconsin

4.74

Rent Door County holds a 4.74 guest rating in Fish Creek, Wisconsin, computed from 207 Airbnb guest reviews across the vacation rentals they manage there. That ranks them 1 of 2 managers in the market on guest satisfaction. See the top ranked vacation rental managers in Fish Creek, or homeowner reviews of Rent Door County on their profile.

Rent Door County's guest rating in Fish Creek, Wisconsin of 4.74 is below average and may adversely impact performance. Some of this can come from specific properties they manage — but where reviews point to manager weaknesses (responsiveness, cleanliness, listing accuracy) that would apply to your home too, they can adversely affect your bookings and the quality of guests you attract. You can see higher-rated managers in Fish Creek.

Recent guest reviews in Fish Creek

NicoleSeptember 2026
“We absolutely loved the location, setting, privacy, and value of this home. It was the perfect house for our group, and overall we had a great stay. We would definitely consider coming back! The biggest downside was the cleanliness, particularly the bedding. We found dirty socks in one of the beds and a water bottle left behind. Some of the sheets had stains and did not smell freshly laundered, which made us question whether they had been changed. The beds also had quilts rather than comforters, and those did not appear to have been recently cleaned either. Based on our experience, I would recommend bringing your own linens/bedding until the cleaning concerns are addressed. There were also quite a few hornets around the porch, which made it difficult to enjoy the outdoor space at times. That said, we really did love the property itself. The location, privacy, space, and price were fantastic, and with some improvements to the cleaning, this would be an amazing place to stay.”
airbnb
ToddSeptember 2026
“This is an excellent location in Fish Creek. The house is nice situated on the water and it is a nice property.”
airbnb
ShelbySeptember 2026
“Great location and house was well appointed.”
airbnb
CristinaSeptember 2026
“Great spot for a family weekend! Perfect location with a lot in walking distance. A beautiful common area and outdoor area to spend time in. Would definitely recommend!”
airbnb
ChristinaSeptember 2026
“Had a great stay here. The house is lovely and very accommodating. Very quiet neighborhood and plenty of room to walk and play with the dog. House was clean and had all accessories (soap, towels, linens, dishsoap, laundry detergent, paper towels, tp, etc). House is 1 mile to center of town along busy road, or can walk there along beautiful Cottage Row, but that's about 3-miles.”
airbnb