Manager Review

Rent Door County in Fish Creek, Wisconsin

4.74

This is the local review page for Rent Door County in Fish Creek, Wisconsin. Amongst managers in Fish Creek, Rent Door County currently ranks 2 of 3 on guest satisfaction. See the top ranked vacation rental managers in Fish Creek, or see homeowner reviews of Rent Door County on their profile.

Rent Door County's guest rating in Fish Creek, Wisconsin of 4.74 is below average and may adversely impact performance. Some of this can come from specific properties they manage — but where reviews point to manager weaknesses (responsiveness, cleanliness, listing accuracy) that would apply to your home too, they can adversely affect your bookings and the quality of guests you attract. You can see higher-rated managers in Fish Creek.

Recent guest reviews

EmilyJune 2026
Great location, kitchen, living space and yard. Found the hospitality somewhat challenging - beds are not fully made, you need to do sheets yourself; towels need to be washed and dried prior to leaving at checkout; no shampoo, body wash etc; only one shower has a door. Yard is not fully fenced as an FYI and there are chips in the tile floor that can be challenging for families. Good location but for the price these are concerns I’d rather not have.
airbnb
KarenJune 2026
Amazing property that is right outside the entrance to Peninsula State Park and in a few minutes walk of the main stretch of town and the beach. Bonus points for being a 3 minute walk from Not Licked Yet (best frozen custard) and Wild Tomato Pizza (great wood-fire pizza). The house itself was very spacious and gorgeous, with a large high-end kitchen and dining area that easily accommodated our large group. Bonus points for each bedroom having its own attached full bathroom, making evening wind-down and morning start-ups easy, even with a mix of adults and small children. Lots of space outdoors on the property as well, with a great fire pit and a propane grill for home cooking. The kids loved learning how to play foosball and shuffle board in the game room. Other reviews have called out that the main living room doesn't have window treatments, but this didn't really bother our group. All bedrooms and the kitchen/dining area did have window covers, which met our needs.
airbnb
CarrieJune 2026
This home was perfect for our family of 8! The location was close to everything we wanted to do/see and the host was amazing at communicating with us. We will absolutely be back! Thank you!
airbnb
LesleyJune 2026
Third annual trip for our family at this stay. We love the proximity to town. Fun to just be able to walk out the door and walk anywhere in Fish Creek. Love the four spacious bedrooms. Always clean!
airbnb
RuthJune 2026
Great location on a private road. Layout of the house was good.
airbnb