Manager Review

Lake Anna Island Rentals reviews in Orange, Virginia

4.68

Lake Anna Island Rentals holds a 4.68 guest rating in Orange, Virginia, computed from 19 guest reviews across the vacation rentals they manage there. That ranks them 3 of 4 managers in the market on guest satisfaction. See the top ranked vacation rental managers in Orange, or homeowner reviews of Lake Anna Island Rentals on their profile.

Lake Anna Island Rentals's guest rating in Orange, Virginia of 4.68 is below average and may adversely impact performance. Some of this can come from specific properties they manage — but where reviews point to manager weaknesses (responsiveness, cleanliness, listing accuracy) that would apply to your home too, they can adversely affect your bookings and the quality of guests you attract. You can see higher-rated managers in Orange.

Recent guest reviews in Orange

MonicaSeptember 2026
“Overall, we had a great stay and enjoyed the home. Everything was wonderful for the most part; however, we did experience a significant issue upon arrival. The front entrance was heavily infested with wasps, which prevented us from safely entering the home. Unfortunately, one member of our group was stung. We contacted the host for assistance, but it took some time to receive a response, leaving us unable to access the property for approximately an hour. We were initially asked to try removing the wasps ourselves using a kayak paddle, which we did not feel was a safe or appropriate solution given the circumstances. Eventually, we were able to enter through the garage. Aside from this incident, the stay itself was great. We hope the entrance issue is addressed promptly so future guests can arrive and access the home safely.”
airbnb
CindyJuly 2026
“Fantastic house! Will likely book again!”
airbnb
JamieJune 2026
“Unfortunately, our stay did not match the listing or the premium price. The rental company was responsive when contacted, but there were too many issues. The biggest concern was the lake access. We understand water depth varies by season and is not fully in the owner’s control. However, this dock is in an objectively shallow part of the lake where you can only walk in waist-deep water. It was not swimmable, even for kids, and not safe for jumping or diving. We rented a boat and went to a nearby cove where the water was deep enough to swim and jump in, so this was specific to this house, not Lake Anna overall. The beach was unusable the first day because construction materials were scattered around. The grill had heavy grease buildup and caught fire multiple times, ruining one dinner. A loud alarm saying “fire alarm” went off overnight due to a low battery, waking the whole house, including small children who could not fall back asleep. And there was a wasp nest in the hot tub.”
airbnb
MelissaJune 2026
“We had a wonderful stay at this home. The dock was a great place to hang out and the lake entry was perfect for kayaks and paddle boards. While the deck furniture could use some updating, everything was as described and we had a wonderful time. There was plenty of inside common area spaces for our large group. We would definitely recommend and would love to stay again!”
airbnb
ZachMay 2026
“Great place. As advertised”
airbnb