Manager Review

Bear Lake Luxury Rentals in Garden City, Utah

4.67

This is the local review page for Bear Lake Luxury Rentals in Garden City, Utah. Amongst managers in Garden City, Bear Lake Luxury Rentals currently ranks 8 of 11 on guest satisfaction. See the top ranked vacation rental managers in Garden City, or see homeowner reviews of Bear Lake Luxury Rentals on their profile.

Bear Lake Luxury Rentals's guest rating in Garden City, Utah of 4.67 is below average and may adversely impact performance. Some of this can come from specific properties they manage — but where reviews point to manager weaknesses (responsiveness, cleanliness, listing accuracy) that would apply to your home too, they can adversely affect your bookings and the quality of guests you attract. You can see higher-rated managers in Garden City.

Recent guest reviews

SheriAugust 2026
We truly enjoyed our stay here. Very spacious, with rooms and sleeping arrangements as described. The kitchen was one of the most well stocked of any rental I've stayed at. Beautiful views of the lake. We plan on staying again in future years!
airbnb
NickAugust 2026
Our group enjoyed the stay at the Bear Lake Airbnb. The space is huge and has a nicely appointed kitchen. It is hosted by a company so the experience felt less personal than if it’s a hosted Airbnb by a private owner. In general, the amenities were good, the place was clean, and the beds were comfortable. There were lots of rules listed out but they were easy to comply with for our group (no parties, no smoking, etc.). It seemed as though that was the central focus of a lot of the communication rather than guest comfort. They charge for things like late checkout or early check-in, rather than making a reasonable accommodation if possible or just saying that they can’t make it work. So, it’s a different (more hotel-like) Airbnb experience.
airbnb
SelsaAugust 2026
Place was great, very comfortable with space and beds for the large family gathering we had. There were a few things that didn’t meet our expectation based on what we paid. Grill was super dirty, hot tub water was also brown. There was a dry grape and trash on the dining floor. There wasn’t a mop readily available for guests, meaning that for a spill we used up most of the supplied roll of paper towels. We found a large stain of some sort on a bed skirt. Overall my rating was lower due to cleanliness. They do ask for the floors to be vacuumed and swept before departure and sheets and pillow cases removed but we weren’t met with the same standard upon arrival. We loved having a pool and our kids spent a lot of time in the pool (about two days) but every one of the them developed a skin rash from excessive chlorine exposure. Despite that we had a great time and hope to have a better experience next time.
airbnb
PamelaAugust 2026
We had a great time. Home is lovely! Pickle ball court was a huge hit! The ground floor outside could have been swept better around the doors and furniture. The beds were very comfortable. The house was clean and cozy. We would stay again
airbnb
MirandaAugust 2026
We loved this home! It was great for our large family and great for hosting meals for our whole group. The pool was so fun, and we spent hours there!
airbnb