Manager Review

Bear Lake Lodging reviews in Garden City, Utah

Bear Lake Lodging holds a 4.78 guest rating in Garden City, Utah, computed from 2,235 Airbnb guest reviews across the vacation rentals they manage there. That ranks them 7 of 9 managers in the market on guest satisfaction. See the top ranked vacation rental managers in Garden City, or homeowner reviews of Bear Lake Lodging on their profile.

Bear Lake Lodging's guest rating in Garden City, Utah of 4.78 is below average and may adversely impact performance. Some of this can come from specific properties they manage — but where reviews point to manager weaknesses (responsiveness, cleanliness, listing accuracy) that would apply to your home too, they can adversely affect your bookings and the quality of guests you attract. You can see higher-rated managers in Garden City.

Recent guest reviews in Garden City

DavidNovember 2026
“We were excited about staying here. We had a women’s retreat with over 30+ women who wanted to get away and enjoy some time together. Unfortunately, the very first night they had prepped dinner a head of time to simply put in the oven as Check in is at 4pm. Makes it easy/simple but come to find out the oven didn’t even work. It showed an error code as they tried to use it. This lead to many conversations with the owners/whoever is over the property. The people seemed annoyed. At first said nothing they can do. Thankfully, our group was willing to try/find a solution ourselves. Sending ideas, possible solutions & it lead to someone coming & “googling” the issue. Asked before hand if the ladies tried anything and was told “that’s probably better than I can do.” So the person they sent, really had no clue of what to do with the oven and frankly, didn’t even want to be there. To their credit, they did bring another one by 10:30-11pm that night. Still wasted food & was not a good experience”
airbnb
KyleOctober 2026
“Good place to stay near bear lake, the bathtub had hair in it and some of the pillows didn’t have covers on them. Other than that the view was great and it had everything described in the listing.”
airbnb
ChristopherAugust 2026
“Natalie’s place was mostly as described, except for the broken blinds in the bedroom that wouldn’t close and resulted in a much earlier wake-up than we had planned. It’s hard to fairly rate accommodations where we didn’t get good sleep. But, Natalie was responsive to our texts to alert her, yet offered no resolution and nothing for our inconvenience. It was a missed opportunity for good customer service. I suspect this blind remained broken for a while and may even still be broken for the next guests, despite us being told it was immediately replaced upon our check-out!?”
airbnb
ChristinaAugust 2026
“There was no parking for our boat, as there is no street parking. The overflow parking was full most of the time and there was not enough parking spaces for peak season. The water pump in the basement is extremely loud. Downstairs guest could hear it every time the toilet flushed. Stove was not cleaned before we arrived. Other than that, the house was great. Plenty of bedrooms and adequately stocked with everything you’d need.”
airbnb
LeichaAugust 2026
“The place was decent, but the amount of beds that they say that they sleep. Wasn’t fully disclosed that you’d be sleeping on a cot if you did bring extra people so the place I stayed in was building 891 number four. They didn’t disclose that our guests would be sleeping on cots luckily most of the guests didn’t come so it worked out. The place we were in had a king bed a queen bed, and a bunk bed and then cots in the basement on metal frames that fold.. also there was an outlet in the bathroom on the main level that didn’t work and a jack and Jill bathroom upstairs for the master suite and the extra bedroom so you had to share those. Also, the ceiling fan was rattling and wobbling and the light wasn’t working and you couldn’t use the chain to turn it on and off it was broken and laying on the dresser. Would I use this place again probably because it wasn’t dirty and gross. It was pretty clean. But it is way high up on a hill if you don’t wanna walk down the hill.”
airbnb