Manager Review

Bear Lake Lodging reviews in Garden City, Utah

4.77

Bear Lake Lodging holds a 4.77 guest rating in Garden City, Utah, computed from 2,142 guest reviews across the vacation rentals they manage there. That ranks them 8 of 12 managers in the market on guest satisfaction. See the top ranked vacation rental managers in Garden City, or homeowner reviews of Bear Lake Lodging on their profile.

Bear Lake Lodging's guest rating in Garden City, Utah of 4.77 is below average and may adversely impact performance. Some of this can come from specific properties they manage — but where reviews point to manager weaknesses (responsiveness, cleanliness, listing accuracy) that would apply to your home too, they can adversely affect your bookings and the quality of guests you attract. You can see higher-rated managers in Garden City.

Recent guest reviews in Garden City

ChyrellAugust 2026
“Cute place, good location”
airbnb
AmyAugust 2026
“As published.”
airbnb
ChristopherAugust 2026
“Natalie’s place was mostly as described, except for the broken blinds in the bedroom that wouldn’t close and resulted in a much earlier wake-up than we had planned. It’s hard to fairly rate accommodations where we didn’t get good sleep. But, Natalie was responsive to our texts to alert her, yet offered no resolution and nothing for our inconvenience. It was a missed opportunity for good customer service. I suspect this blind remained broken for a while and may even still be broken for the next guests, despite us being told it was immediately replaced upon our check-out!?”
airbnb
ChristinaAugust 2026
“There was no parking for our boat, as there is no street parking. The overflow parking was full most of the time and there was not enough parking spaces for peak season. The water pump in the basement is extremely loud. Downstairs guest could hear it every time the toilet flushed. Stove was not cleaned before we arrived. Other than that, the house was great. Plenty of bedrooms and adequately stocked with everything you’d need.”
airbnb
ShaylynnAugust 2026
“Beautiful view, clean and fun games the kids loved. No fully stocked shampoo and conditioner. I’ve never stayed in an Airbnb without these. We had three different boats drive down to the end, one being ours and impossible to turn around. Nothing in the Airbnb info that said boats have to park in parking lot at bottom of neighborhood. Had to back boats all the way back down the street. There needs to be a sign at the beginning of the street that says no boat turn around and this info should be included in the description on Airbnb. This was a huge hassle at first. It would have made a major difference if we were just informed.”
airbnb