Manager Review

Magnolia Vacation Rentals reviews in Gatlinburg, Tennessee

4.72

Magnolia Vacation Rentals holds a 4.72 guest rating in Gatlinburg, Tennessee, computed from 675 Airbnb guest reviews across the vacation rentals they manage there. That ranks them 43 of 63 managers in the market on guest satisfaction. See the top ranked vacation rental managers in Gatlinburg, or homeowner reviews of Magnolia Vacation Rentals on their profile.

Magnolia Vacation Rentals's guest rating in Gatlinburg, Tennessee of 4.72 is below average and may adversely impact performance. Some of this can come from specific properties they manage — but where reviews point to manager weaknesses (responsiveness, cleanliness, listing accuracy) that would apply to your home too, they can adversely affect your bookings and the quality of guests you attract. You can see higher-rated managers in Gatlinburg.

Recent guest reviews in Gatlinburg

JordanOctober 2026
“Location was fantastic loved we could walk every where. We did have some issues upon arrival which was upsetting after we had been on the road for 12 hours.”
airbnb
JuliaOctober 2026
“Great location, close walk to the strip.”
airbnb
DeborahAugust 2026
“Great location with an easy, short walk to the Gatlinburg strip. We enjoyed the pool, and the balcony had beautiful views. We even saw a bear right outside, which was really cool! Unfortunately, water continually dripped from the ceiling above the balcony, so we got wet while sitting outside. The biggest issue was comfort. The queen bed was probably the worst we have ever slept on. It was honestly like sleeping directly on a box spring and the pillows were equally uncomfortable. My husband and I gave up around midnight and spent the rest of the night on the couch and recliner, but still couldn’t sleep comfortably. My parents had no complaints about the king bed itself, but their bedroom stayed 77–78 degrees all night despite the AC running. There are definitely great things about this property, especially the location, pool, and views, but the queen mattress/pillows, leaking balcony roof, and cooling issue desperately need to be addressed.”
airbnb
GregoryAugust 2026
“The listing was nice, the issue that I had was that we were not informed that we would be in a unit with construction workers on scaffolding on its outside walls.Every morning fri,sat,sun,mon, banging noises woke us up. People working on the units balcony, no privacy.”
airbnb
JeradJuly 2026
“"Updated Cabin with Screened Hot Tub" was the title description. We had two issues, self resolved: 1) Cabin: We had to track down our access code when Instructions received said we would have them by 11:15am day of arrival. 2) Hot Tub: Would not heat over 90-degrees. On final night, we reached out, and found out we were in maintenance (or similar) mode. Instructions were given, but after I commented that it would have been nice to have a working hot tub from the beginning, I was informed it was my fault because I had not responded to messages that came within the Airbnb app and that's the only way the host could communicate unless I granted them permission otherwise. Was never informed of this when I searched, booked, and paid via the web site, no app involved and we called them via phone for code, so app not required. Our family attempted to use the hot tub for 3 night and could not get it to heat. But my fault because I didn't respond to app messages that I didn't know about.”
airbnb