Manager Review

Magnolia Vacation Rentals in Cosby, Tennessee

4.53

This is the local review page for Magnolia Vacation Rentals in Cosby, Tennessee. Amongst managers in Cosby, Magnolia Vacation Rentals currently ranks 6 of 7 on guest satisfaction. See the top ranked vacation rental managers in Cosby, or see homeowner reviews of Magnolia Vacation Rentals on their profile.

Magnolia Vacation Rentals's guest rating in Cosby, Tennessee of 4.53 is below average and may adversely impact performance. Some of this can come from specific properties they manage — but where reviews point to manager weaknesses (responsiveness, cleanliness, listing accuracy) that would apply to your home too, they can adversely affect your bookings and the quality of guests you attract. You can see higher-rated managers in Cosby.

Recent guest reviews

ShannonJune 2026
It was nice area. The cleanliness of the place and broken patio furniture as a disappointment. Be sure to have all you need with you. Overall, my family had a good time.
airbnb
MarkJune 2026
It was a great place to stay!! We had a group of 12 and there was plenty of room. The kids loved it. We will definitely be back!
airbnb
DanielMay 2026
Overall, the cabin had several enjoyable features, but there were cleanliness, maintenance, and safety concerns that impacted our stay. We appreciated the plenty of towels/washcloths, comfortable downstairs master beds, coffee pot with pod and ground options, children’s pool floaties, extra trundle beds, and relaxing porch swing/rocking chairs. The peaceful view and kid-friendly play area were also great. The air conditioning went out during our stay but was fixed promptly, which we appreciated. However, the trash was never emptied for eight days despite requesting service twice. Cleanliness was a concern: dirty dishes with food crumbs and grease stains, dusty/dirty floors we had to sweep immediately, dirty sheets in one bedroom, and toothpaste-like residue on bathroom walls. Maintenance concerns included a broken blender, no vacuum, slow drain, and an unstable upstairs bathroom floor that posed a safety concern. Two guests were also stung by dirt dauber bees on the porch.
airbnb
VickieMay 2026
The cabin is very outdated. Could definitely use an update on furniture up and wore out. Dishes were dirty. The fridge/refrigerator was having trouble closing. Most of the drawers were broke. The beds were all pretty wore out too can feel springs and a lot of of the mattresses definitely needs a good cleaning, dusting all that. Lot of the chairs that go with the table were broken and spots still use both up broken. The pool kept running short on water for some reason and wasn’t filtering through because the water was too low so as loud and noisy.
airbnb
StephenMay 2026
It was good the kids loved it
airbnb