Manager Review

Stay In The Black Hills reviews in Custer, South Dakota

4.87

Stay In The Black Hills holds a 4.87 guest rating in Custer, South Dakota, computed from 1,399 Airbnb guest reviews across the vacation rentals they manage there. That ranks them 1 of 2 managers in the market on guest satisfaction. See the top ranked vacation rental managers in Custer, or homeowner reviews of Stay In The Black Hills on their profile.

Recent guest reviews in Custer

SarahOctober 2026
“Absolutely beautiful cabin in the Black Hills. We loved so much of what this place offered. Things I wanted to take a minute to let others know ahead of time. In previous reviews the AC didn't work, and it still wasn't working when we got there. Also, the fireplace isn't working. We messaged them with pictures and they said it was set to the highest setting and wouldn't increase any further, which it was barely lit. No flame, and little heat. Again, not a huge deal for us but if that is something your booking this for just know it isn't working currently. The road is still washed out also. We had 4x4 vehicles, but if you are in a smaller vehicle you might have trouble getting up the driveway. Flies and wasps are around but it didn't bother us, I just did a quick vacuum every now and again to get them wiped up. Things I loved: the wildlife around here is so fun! We woke up to turkeys and deer daily. The air is crisp and clean. Kids had an absolute blast with the game room!”
airbnb
JonathanJune 2026
“Great place in a great location to visit the black hills! The gravel road caught us off guard at first, but we had no issue finding the place and loved that it was private and peaceful at the top of a hill. We would definitely spend time here again if the opportunity arises! The hosts were very responsive, replying in a matter of minutes most of the time. Very pleased, definitely recommend this place!”
airbnb
KatieJune 2026
“Our first time using and AirBnb and it exceeded our expectations. The location was great, private, and located within 30 minutes of everything we wanted to do. The kitchen was spacious, and a great gathering place for our big group. Beds were cozy. The hot tub and yard games provided made the evenings very enjoyable. Lastly, the host was responsive, and very helpful with any questions. Recommend to anyone!”
airbnb
BeverlyJune 2026
“Enjoyed our stay! The house was clean and the host was responsive. Kitchen is well stocked. Quick drive to downtown Custer. Saw 3 deer and a cute fawn in the yard. Highly recommend this home!”
airbnb
JayciJune 2026
“Beautiful spot, exactly like the photos. Host was extremely responsive, which I appreciate because I tend to be an over-communicator. 4 stars instead of 5 because the beds were so uncomfortable, we did not sleep well. This was a tough pill because of the pricey reservation.”
airbnb