Manager Review

First Choice Lodging Company in Nelsonville, Ohio

4.59

This is the local review page for First Choice Lodging Company in Nelsonville, Ohio. Amongst managers in Nelsonville, First Choice Lodging Company currently ranks 2 of 2 on guest satisfaction. See the top ranked vacation rental managers in Nelsonville, or see homeowner reviews of First Choice Lodging Company on their profile.

First Choice Lodging Company's guest rating in Nelsonville, Ohio of 4.59 is below average and may adversely impact performance. Some of this can come from specific properties they manage — but where reviews point to manager weaknesses (responsiveness, cleanliness, listing accuracy) that would apply to your home too, they can adversely affect your bookings and the quality of guests you attract. You can see higher-rated managers in Nelsonville.

Recent guest reviews

May 2026
“We were in town for a funeral to be close to family. Everything was very clean. We came with 3 kids that were 4 and under and felt very comfortable in this home.”
airbnb
May 2026
“Excelente demasiado para disfrutar de la vida”
airbnb
May 2026
“We had a wonderful mini trip, great property, very private and peaceful!”
airbnb
May 2026
“We loved our stay! It was very private and peaceful! Sat on the front porch a lot and enjoyed the view and wildlife while eating grilled steaks. Even during a downpour it was nice to be able to sit out there. Everything was as described.”
airbnb
VictoriaMay 2026
“We booked this property SOLELY because the listing specifically advertised and pictured a “fenced-in area” that would provide a safe environment for dogs. Unfortunately, upon arrival, the yard was not actually fenced at all. As pet owners traveling with our dogs, this was a major factor in choosing this Airbnb, so it was very disappointing and extremely inconvenient. We spent over 3k and traveled 7 hours to specifically be at this air bnb with a large fenced yard. We Would never have came here otherwise. Because of this, our entire weekend became much more stressful and difficult than expected and made it hard to relax or fully enjoy the weekend. We brought our concerns to the host, and while they offered a $100 refund, it does not nearly make up for the inconvenience or the completely inaccurate description and false advertising.”
airbnb