Manager Review

Oak Island Accommodations in North Carolina

Oak Island Accommodations's guest reviews across North Carolina. See homeowner reviews of Oak Island Accommodations on their profile.

Oak Island Accommodations's guest rating in North Carolina of 4.60 is below average and may adversely impact performance. Some of this can come from specific properties they manage — but where reviews point to manager weaknesses (responsiveness, cleanliness, listing accuracy) that would apply to your home too, they can adversely affect your bookings and the quality of guests you attract. You can see higher-rated managers in North Carolina.

Recent guest reviews

AnthonyJune 2026Caswell Beach
My wife and kids loved the privacy and quietness of the area. We were looking for a beach that wasn’t overcrowded and Caswell was exactly that. The condo was very nice, clean, and accommodating for all five of us. Spent most of our days on the beach and at the pool . We toured around Oak Island and Southport for fresh seafood and local shopping. It had everything we needed! We will be sure to return soon and look forward to our next trip.
airbnb
JudithJune 2026Caswell Beach
The stay was amazing! Everything was wonderful beach access was perfect! The WW1 wall was definitely worth a tour! The only thing we had one neighbor who was a bit aggressive with us when we had a guest over that did not exceed the limit! Other than that everything was perfect!
airbnb
MariaJune 2026Caswell Beach
Arrived to a different OIA house w/ broken AC. We were relocated to Fairwinds within an hour and a half. I appreciate how quick and kind the OIA employees were when resolving this issue. The house was really big and extremely clean. Kitchen has a bunch of cooking and serving implements. Area was quiet and peaceful- the beach felt almost private because there aren't a ton of houses in this part of the island. Beautiful house and wonderful stay!
airbnb
MacMay 2026Caswell Beach
This house was perfect in every way that didn’t involve the management group. The layout is fantastic for a large family: bathrooms for every bedroom, a well-equipped kitchen, 3 fridges, large dining areas, multiple outdoor hangout spaces, beach access deckway, outdoor shower, and beautiful views. It’s hard to imagine a better-designed house for a family gathering. Unfortunately, management soured the experience immediately by cutting corners on basics. Their starter kit included just 3 rolls of toilet paper for a house with 8 bathrooms, leaving 5 bathrooms without any TP. Most bathrooms lacked hand soap, the kitchen had almost no dish soap, and there were no extra trash bags or paper products. When we asked for enough essentials to get through the first night, we were told nothing more would be provided, so we spent our first evening shopping for toilet paper and soap. At this price point, basic supplies should be included. Despite this, we enjoyed our stay and the house was amazing.
airbnb
LukeMay 2026Oak Island
It was fine. The best part o the place is how easy it is to leave and be on the beach. The view of the ocean is obstructed a bit by the dune but what can you do, dunes are important. For 3k a week you’d expect the dishwasher to be seated properly open easily and not easily pull out from the counter. Having to push back in an air vent, the screens left on the deck and what we think was a fire alarm covered in painters tape were charming touches. It’s a beach house so sand happens, we swept with the broom provided only to realize there is no dust pan (luckily there was a vacuum). Early check in and check out were offered via text which would have been delightful surprises had they not just been schemes to bleed an additional $100 out of you.
airbnb

Amongst managers in North Carolina, Oak Island Accommodations currently ranks 55/78 on guest satisfaction. See the top ranked vacation rental managers in North Carolina.