Manager Review

Plushy in Fayetteville, North Carolina

3.90

This is the local review page for Plushy in Fayetteville, North Carolina. Amongst managers in Fayetteville, Plushy currently ranks 4 of 4 on guest satisfaction. See the top ranked vacation rental managers in Fayetteville, or see homeowner reviews of Plushy on their profile.

Plushy's guest rating in Fayetteville, North Carolina of 3.90 is below average and may adversely impact performance. Some of this can come from specific properties they manage — but where reviews point to manager weaknesses (responsiveness, cleanliness, listing accuracy) that would apply to your home too, they can adversely affect your bookings and the quality of guests you attract. You can see higher-rated managers in Fayetteville.

Recent guest reviews

LisaAugust 2026
We decided we could not stay in the home due to the musty smell covered over by a high chemical smell and the horrible stains on the carpet. The Host said they were going to have carpet cleaned which I believe will alleviate both issues. Unfortunately since our stay was only for 3 nights the cleaning did not occur during the time frame we were supposed to stay in the home. We had traveled an hour out of town for the accommodations but were unable to stay in the home. We had to make other arrangements for our stay.
airbnb
KennethJuly 2026
Definitely great place to stay with family or friends to grill out. Also a lot of space in the backyard to chill.
airbnb
AndreaJuly 2026
When prepping to check in, the host did not send the keypad code for the door. I had to reach out again to obtain, upon arrival the gate code was not working, I had to ask other individuals living in the same area for assistance on how to get access. The house smelled like it had been smoked in, bugs present. Neighbors were loud and unfriendly. Person was sent for maintenance work but things worked fine. It seemed like an excuse to just get in, if I wasn't present they were going to go in regardless with all my personal items inside. Witnessed fights outside, missing packages, etc. They attempted to charge for another week without authorization after a $0 cancelation. Paid for an entire month and after two weeks they wanted me to pay half of what was due the next month, after denying to pay, I canceled and they immediately changed the pin code, locking me out of all my belongings. They gave me access after I mentioned involving authorities and after contacting support. Horrid. 0 stars.
airbnb
ShaJuly 2026
Lovely home!
airbnb
BrianaMay 2026
I love my stay! Very peaceful.
airbnb