Manager Review

StayMarquis in Water Mill, New York

4.73

This is the local review page for StayMarquis in Water Mill, New York. See homeowner reviews of StayMarquis on their profile.

StayMarquis's guest rating in Water Mill, New York of 4.73 is below average and may adversely impact performance. Some of this can come from specific properties they manage — but where reviews point to manager weaknesses (responsiveness, cleanliness, listing accuracy) that would apply to your home too, they can adversely affect your bookings and the quality of guests you attract. You can see higher-rated managers in Water Mill.

Recent guest reviews

AnteApril 2026
Such a wonderful home for a stay. Clean and perfect layout! The sauna is a huge plus especially for an off season escape.
airbnb
November 2025
We booked this stay for my birthday to celebrate with friends, but unfortunately this stay was extremely disappointing esp for how expensive it is. The listing heavily advertises a hot tub in the title and amenities and even appears in Airbnb’s hot-tub filter, yet it was completely unavailable. The only note was buried deep in the description, which felt misleading and left us feeling deceived. The host kept saying we “weren’t charged the hot-tub premium,” but that doesn’t change that the listing presents it as included. The home also does not match the photos; much of it feels like a fixer-upper, especially the basement, and one bathroom had no hot water. The host was inflexible throughout the stay. Overall, the listing does not match what is advertised, and I hope it’s updated for future guests. The mismatch between the listing and reality made this stay far below expectations. Transparency matters, and this property needs clearer, more accurate representation.
airbnb
October 2025
Perfect place for a stay in the hamptons. Everything was as advertised and the process, communication, etc. were all very smooth. Will be staying here next time!
airbnb
October 2025
The house was beautiful, everything was as described in the listing. We will definitely seek out StayMarquis for our trip next year!
airbnb
September 2025
Enjoyed our stay
airbnb