Manager Review

Vacasa in New York

Vacasa's guest reviews across New York. See homeowner reviews of Vacasa on their profile.

Vacasa's guest rating in New York of 4.58 is below average and may adversely impact performance. Some of this can come from specific properties they manage — but where reviews point to manager weaknesses (responsiveness, cleanliness, listing accuracy) that would apply to your home too, they can adversely affect your bookings and the quality of guests you attract. You can see higher-rated managers in New York.

Recent guest reviews

AdelaideMay 2026Wevertown
Great place. Peaceful!
airbnb
RohanMay 2026Lake George
Loved our stay at the property. It’s located uphill with beautiful views of lake George and neighborhood within 3 mins of walking distance. The property has enough bathroom and private spaces for 6 people. We loved the finished basement and the indoor fireplace. We have been at the lake 5+ times staying in different spots every-time. We hope to book this place again for the next time!
airbnb
NicoleMay 2026Penn Yan
Our stay at Vacasa Arizona's home was overall lovely! There was plenty of space for the 10 of us to sleep, and we never felt cramped in the kitchen or living room when hanging out. The outdoor area is gorgeous, with a lovely view of the lake. The pre-check in process is very tedious with paperwork provided by the host to complete with the names/DOB of everyone attending. Additionally we had a problem with the fridge when we visited, contact customer support, and never received an answer. Early check in/late check out do not seem to be items they flexibly accommodate. Lastly, this did not bug us, but there were ants all over the property. They had some spray under the sink to use, but that part of it made it feel like we were camping! The house is overall stunning and was VERY clean. We loved the location, but likely would not stay again.
airbnb
RoxanneMay 2026Penn Yan
The neighborhood was peaceful and the home was very clean. Gaining access to the home was a bit of a challenge and during our stay one of the bedroom doors got locked, and there were no clear instructions on how to open the door in case that happened. Communication was poor with the host but overall, we enjoyed our time there.
airbnb
AllisonMay 2026Keuka Park
We had a wonderful stay at this home. It was very clean, comfortable, and organized. We love the location and all that Keuka Lake has to offer.
airbnb

Amongst managers in New York, Vacasa currently ranks 14/15 on guest satisfaction. See the top ranked vacation rental managers in New York.