Manager Review

Vacasa in Penn Yan, New York

4.60

This is the local review page for Vacasa in Penn Yan, New York. Amongst managers in Penn Yan, Vacasa currently ranks 4 of 4 on guest satisfaction. See the top ranked vacation rental managers in Penn Yan, or see homeowner reviews of Vacasa on their profile.

Vacasa's guest rating in Penn Yan, New York of 4.60 is below average and may adversely impact performance. Some of this can come from specific properties they manage — but where reviews point to manager weaknesses (responsiveness, cleanliness, listing accuracy) that would apply to your home too, they can adversely affect your bookings and the quality of guests you attract. You can see higher-rated managers in Penn Yan.

Recent guest reviews

IanJune 2026
“Beautiful home”
airbnb
KyleJune 2026
“Amazing place to stay on Keuka Lake. The house was clean, comfortable, and had incredible views. The location was perfect, and everything was exactly as advertised. We had a great experience from start to finish and would absolutely stay here again. Highly recommend!”
airbnb
KevinJune 2026
“Nice lakehouse that accommodated our group. It's right on the water which was nice for a swim and kayaks. The included kayaks were great for our group to use, and the firepit on the lake was nice. This is a lakefront property so there were a lot of bugs, particularly mayflies and stinkbugs that found their way in the house. There's also only 1 wall mounted AC unit for the main house, but plenty of fans were provided.”
airbnb
GaryJune 2026
“Great house. nice and clean. Arcade game is a nice touch. Plenty of beds. Nice fire pit by the water. Had a great time”
airbnb
DuganJune 2026
“Nice and old historic house. No real serious complaints. Would just be prepared to be in contact with a corporate company that communicates through customer service representatives, rather than the owner/resident. Made a lot of the communications more difficult than they had to be as a result.”
airbnb