Manager Review

Skelly Properties reviews in Penn Yan, New York

4.82

Skelly Properties holds a 4.82 guest rating in Penn Yan, New York, computed from 780 guest reviews across the vacation rentals they manage there. That ranks them 5 of 8 managers in the market on guest satisfaction. See the top ranked vacation rental managers in Penn Yan, or homeowner reviews of Skelly Properties on their profile.

Recent guest reviews in Penn Yan

DaisySeptember 2026
“this was a great place to stay. i like that it was clutter free. and the lake isn't that far away”
airbnb
ElizabethSeptember 2026
“The covered wagon stay was a great and unique experience to have. There’s nothing like it. Make sure to ask for s’mores if you want it. Bring bottled water for the Kurig because this place has sulfur water. Futon is not that comfortable but all in all it’s a really cool stay! I even brought a cowboy hat! Lol!”
airbnb
JessicaSeptember 2026
“Great weekend stay! Exactly how it was described. Enjoyable amenities and closely located wineries.”
airbnb
DaveSeptember 2026
“This was a fun spot for a quick night away, never thought id spend a night in a covered wagon!”
airbnb
JuliaSeptember 2026
“The covered wagon was lovely and very comfortable.”
airbnb