Manager Review

Skelly Properties reviews in Penn Yan, New York

Skelly Properties holds a 4.82 guest rating in Penn Yan, New York, computed from 824 Airbnb guest reviews across the vacation rentals they manage there. That ranks them 3 of 6 managers in the market on guest satisfaction. See the top ranked vacation rental managers in Penn Yan, or homeowner reviews of Skelly Properties on their profile.

Recent guest reviews in Penn Yan

ScottNovember 2026
“Location was perfect, the yurt sat back far enough from the road where we had dark skies, privacy and quiet nights. The yurt itself had everything we needed for the weekend and worked out perfectly. There’s lots to do in the area without all the crowds of some of the other lakes, while still being centralized enough to visit them.”
airbnb
JenniferNovember 2026
“The place is perfect if you are looking for a cool, unique experience. Unfortunately, the shower pressure and the smell of the water was awful.”
airbnb
BillNovember 2026
“This was our first time staying in a different type of lodging, and it was definitely enjoyable!! Plenty of space and very comfortable for a quiet relaxing weekend.”
airbnb
MarkOctober 2026
“Great space. Close to wineries. Charming location and a unique experience. As described and shown in pictures. Will definitely visit again.”
airbnb
C AOctober 2026
“So great to stay in such a clean dog friendly home.”
airbnb