Finger Lakes Premier Properties reviews in Penn Yan, New York

“We were in town for a friend’s wedding. The house was in a great location and walkable to the places we needed to go. It was clean and as described”

“My husband and I had 9 friends join us for a long weekend on Keuka Lake. The house was perfect for our large party. It was close to many of our favorite wineries. And the kitchen had everything we needed for making our many meals together. The view of the lake from the porch was stellar! We spent a few nights out there enjoying the view and each others company. Thank you for sharing your home!”

“Disappointed for girls weekend trip. The house is gorgeous but not well maintained. The windows were covered in dead bugs and spiderwebs-both inside and out. There were many live spiders, flies, and cockroaches inside of the home as well. The WiFi did not work at all and there is little service at this spot. Apple/google Maps were inaccurate. The drive way is extremely steep and they do not send the rules until after you book- which is a limit of 4 cars and the road does not have limo/bus access for winery tours. Extremely unhelpful when you’re messaging them, - very corporate-ai response instead of a real person. We paid a lot of $ for 2 nights at this home that only included small single use hand soaps and barely enough cleaning supplies like extra trash bags or paper towels for a home that allows a dozen people to stay there and expects all chores to be done. Not even coffee was provided and there was no place to get some for 30+ minutes. Could be 5 stars, but not maintained well.”

“Beautiful location with space for the group to spread out. Huge lakeside deck with SUPs and kayaks to use. Convenient to town and local wineries. We’d stay there again!”

“Firstly , it’s really a huge home with 5 bedroom designed for 12 people , but the problem is they have only 2 half bath rooms and we thought we can adjust , but non of the bedrooms or master bath is having lock on the door. So it is designed to have only 2 or max 3 families. And more over it has very less supplies like one napkin roll and only 2 dishwasher liquid , so if you planning to say more than a day buy and go as every thing from this home is more than 45 mins”