Manager Review

Finger Lakes Premier Properties in Penn Yan, New York

4.63

This is the local review page for Finger Lakes Premier Properties in Penn Yan, New York. Amongst managers in Penn Yan, Finger Lakes Premier Properties currently ranks 6 of 7 on guest satisfaction. See the top ranked vacation rental managers in Penn Yan, or see homeowner reviews of Finger Lakes Premier Properties on their profile.

Finger Lakes Premier Properties's guest rating in Penn Yan, New York of 4.63 is below average and may adversely impact performance. Some of this can come from specific properties they manage — but where reviews point to manager weaknesses (responsiveness, cleanliness, listing accuracy) that would apply to your home too, they can adversely affect your bookings and the quality of guests you attract. You can see higher-rated managers in Penn Yan.

Recent guest reviews

RobynAugust 2026
Good sized house for a family stay on the lake
airbnb
MeganAugust 2026
A true lakeside retreat! We watched the perseids and played in the water! Rain or shine, it was a fantastic place to gather. Easy to find, great to relax in, and not far from sweet adventures.
airbnb
JeanneAugust 2026
This worked out perfectly for my family. It's not fancy, but the in town location and 4 beds was great.
airbnb
JoanneAugust 2026
Nice cottage….bedrooms are tight. Outside is amazing….nice dock, eating area, no steps to the water. Good parking.
airbnb
SarahJuly 2026
Loved the layout of the house, the dock was perfect for fishing/swimming and the multiple hangout spots were great. There is electric in the small shed and tons of bonus toys/floats/etc. A few things to note: the dishwasher was noticeably broken (they sent someone out to fix it the following day but it was unrepairable) and the cleaning could be improved (perfume on throw blankets, crumbs under ottomans that were clearly not moved, hair/urine odor in bathroom) While the place has air conditioning, two are floor units making the dining/bedroom tight. Most, if not all, of the exterior path lights don’t work so getting to the dock at night is dangerous. The house sits right next to a drain so when it rains you have a built in waterfall but also a very mucky area of the lake. Lastly, the dogs next door seem friendly but they bark…a lot. Overall, a nice place but nowhere near nice enough for the price we paid.
airbnb