Manager Review

Cooperstown Stay reviews in Oneonta, New York

Cooperstown Stay holds a 4.87 guest rating in Oneonta, New York, computed from 268 Airbnb guest reviews across the vacation rentals they manage there. That ranks them 3 of 3 managers in the market on guest satisfaction. See the top ranked vacation rental managers in Oneonta, or homeowner reviews of Cooperstown Stay on their profile.

Recent guest reviews in Oneonta

ShaunOctober 2026
“Everything was as advertised. The host was responsive and the house is well equipped! The location is great for walking downtown to Oneonta and to get to the Suny Oneonta/Hartwick. There is off street parking (great) on a very busy street, if you have young/old ones need to exercise caution crossing the busy road. This was a great experience with this host.”
airbnb
TinaOctober 2026
“Kimberly was super friendly and helpful. She was great with communication! House was cute and private, as shown in the listing.”
airbnb
CherylAugust 2026
“Great communication helped make the stay effortless!”
airbnb
LuciaAugust 2026
“Our host Dave was absolutely wonderful! He even waited for us until the Cooperstown parade ended so he could let us in such a thoughtful touch. Anything we needed, like extra garbage bags, he was quick to help with. The place was spotless and well taken care of. Highly recommend staying here great communication and hospitality from start to finish!”
airbnb
LauraAugust 2026
“This cottage was absolutely gorgeous inside and out. The owners were so responsive, flexible, and welcoming! I would recommend this home time and time again!”
airbnb