Manager Review

Cooperstown Stay reviews in Milford, New York

Cooperstown Stay holds a 4.95 guest rating in Milford, New York, computed from 60 Airbnb guest reviews across the vacation rentals they manage there. See the top ranked vacation rental managers in Milford, or homeowner reviews of Cooperstown Stay on their profile.

Recent guest reviews in Milford

MorganSeptember 2026
“Great spot to stay for tournaments at the All Star Village.”
airbnb
DianaAugust 2026
“Our family thoroughly enjoyed our recent stay. The proximity to Cooperstown Dreams Park was highly convenient, contributing to a very positive experience. Thank you again!”
airbnb
DebraAugust 2026
“This house has so much to offer! We loved the huge kitchen where everyone could dine around the large table. Plenty of seating for simultaneous board games. It sleeps 10 people extremely comfortably. The house was extremely well equipped with spices, coffee pots, cooking tools, dishes, and first aid supplies! The children loved catching frogs and salamanders in the pond and playing ping pong, corn hole, and foosball. We also made smores one night. My nephew was playing baseball at Dreams Park, so we were there every day. It was only a 15-minute drive through the beautiful countryside. A few minutes more and you were in Cooperstown where there are plenty of restaurants and ice cream shops. We will definitely stay there again if my grandson plays there next year.”
airbnb
JeffreyAugust 2026
“The location was perfect for our trip to Cooperstown Dreams Park. Close enough to the fields that it was easy to drive back and forth between games. Being on the river there were kayaks, fishing and wildlife to keep us entertained. Plenty of space and activities.”
airbnb
SteveAugust 2026
“Cozy as advertised, the one-bedroom near Cooperstown Dreams Park was a quiet retreat. The small farm setting made it feel peaceful and welcoming. Kevin the pig was an absolute highlight—such a great greeter. The room matched the description, and was comfortable. Overall, a nice stay with warm touches.”
airbnb