Manager Review

StayMarquis in Mattituck, New York

4.60

This is the local review page for StayMarquis in Mattituck, New York. Amongst managers in Mattituck, StayMarquis currently ranks 2 of 2 on guest satisfaction. See the top ranked vacation rental managers in Mattituck, or see homeowner reviews of StayMarquis on their profile.

StayMarquis's guest rating in Mattituck, New York of 4.60 is below average and may adversely impact performance. Some of this can come from specific properties they manage — but where reviews point to manager weaknesses (responsiveness, cleanliness, listing accuracy) that would apply to your home too, they can adversely affect your bookings and the quality of guests you attract. You can see higher-rated managers in Mattituck.

Recent guest reviews

GerardAugust 2026
Host was unobtrusive but extremely responsive and helpful. House was great. Very positive experience overall.
airbnb
September 2025
There was no closet space. Closets were either locked or FILLED with owners things. Had a maintenance issue while we were there. Communication from StayMarquis was not great. It happened at night and apparently, the overnight report wasn’t read until the next morning
airbnb
July 2025
This house was an absolute gem for our Fourth of July weekend! The massive yard and stunning water views gave us a private fireworks show from the dock. We loved kayaking and roasting marshmallows by the epic firepit, complete with a fun tree swing. When we initially arrived there was some confusion over which dock belonged to which house, but Daniel was on it faster than we could say 'cannonball.' The pool was a refreshing oasis, even if we had to embrace a few leaves as swimming companions (a skimmer would've been nice, but we're not picky and nothing kept us from taking more than a few dips!). Just a heads-up for larger groups: consider BYO beach chairs for the pool so everyone has a spot to lounge (about 3 loungers, 2 beach chairs, and adirondacks are available at the house). All in all, a phenomenal stay and easily a 10/10, 5-star experience! Prepare for pure bliss (and maybe a little friendly competition for the tree swing!).
airbnb
June 2025
Great location. Management staff was super responsive to the few questions we had. We had tons of room and house was beautiful.
airbnb
August 2023
One of my best experience.
airbnb