Manager Review

Watchful Eye Caretaking & Property Management, LLC in Margaretville, New York

4.91

This is the local review page for Watchful Eye Caretaking & Property Management, LLC in Margaretville, New York. Amongst managers in Margaretville, Watchful Eye Caretaking & Property Management, LLC currently ranks 2 of 3 on guest satisfaction. See the top ranked vacation rental managers in Margaretville, or see homeowner reviews of Watchful Eye Caretaking & Property Management, LLC on their profile.

Recent guest reviews

AlexandraAugust 2026
Had a wonderful 2 day stay here - just what was needed! Home was stocked, sauna - hot tub worked well and had a very relaxing trip. Would definetly book another trip. Host was incredible!
airbnb
LloydAugust 2026
Everything was as advertised was a lovely weekend. Thanks to Kimberly.
airbnb
StaceyAugust 2026
My family and I had a wonderful stay at this home in Margaretville. We especially enjoyed the peaceful surroundings, the hot tub, and the game room, which made for a relaxing getaway. The home was very clean, and Kim was responsive and easy to communicate with throughout our stay. The upscale appliances were a nice touch, although some were a little different to operate and took a bit of figuring out. We never did figure out the microwave 😂We also would have appreciated a few more basic kitchen and household supplies, such as aluminum foil, plastic baggies, plastic wrap, kitchen towels and laundry detergent. Overall, we had a great experience and would happily stay here again
airbnb
GideonAugust 2026
Beautiful well maintained spot. Really everything about it was perfect except two very small things: 1. The BBQ is more of a fire pit with a net. Difficult to cook with it as the coals are far from the net. 2. The house runs on well water, some might prefer it but for us the water tastes off. I’d bring your own drinking water Host was communicative and helpful. Sauna is amazing
airbnb
NathalieJuly 2026
The place was beautiful, private and peaceful. Home had everything you would need to cook and wood for the bonfire/grill, household essentials. Host responded quickly to any questions I had. Would definitely stay again.
airbnb