Manager Review

Watchful Eye Caretaking & Property Management, LLC in Margaretville, New York

4.92

This is the local review page for Watchful Eye Caretaking & Property Management, LLC in Margaretville, New York. See homeowner reviews of Watchful Eye Caretaking & Property Management, LLC on their profile.

Recent guest reviews

Anja LouiseMay 2026
We had a great stay in the Brookside Cottage with our toddler. The space was very cozy and had plenty of space for two adults and a child. The house was very well equipped and even had some helpful extras, including a high chair. The house is perfectly located in terms of proximity to Margaretville while also being private - it was so nice not to always have to get in the car, and we loved strolling down to pick up coffee and other essentials! Finally, Kimberlie was super response when we had a question, which we really appreciated. Thank you!
airbnb
May 2026
We had a wonderful stay at the cabin last weekend. The property is very well thought out, with modern, brand-new amenities throughout and a highly practical design. Everything was spotless, and the instructions provided were clear and easy to follow. The large windows offer beautiful views of the surrounding nature, making it easy to relax and unwind. It was the perfect setting for our weekend getaway. Even though the weather was rainy, we thoroughly enjoyed our stay. As an added bonus, the local gym and pool are just a few minutes away by car, which gave us great indoor options when spending time outside wasn't ideal. We would happily stay here again.
airbnb
HarshalMay 2026
Kimberlie is a great host and the property was amazing.
airbnb
SeanMay 2026
We loved staying here. Kimberlie was great and very responsive. Beds are very comfortable, loved the sauna and hot tub. It’s a very private, peaceful location and near some good hiking and golf.
airbnb
May 2026
Quaint spot in the Catskills. If you’re looking for a remote and quiet spot to use as a Homebase to explore the region, this is a great option.
airbnb