Manager Review

Vacasa in Keuka Park, New York

4.80

This is the local review page for Vacasa in Keuka Park, New York. Amongst managers in Keuka Park, Vacasa currently ranks 3 of 4 on guest satisfaction. See the top ranked vacation rental managers in Keuka Park, or see homeowner reviews of Vacasa on their profile.

Recent guest reviews

LindseyAugust 2026
We enjoyed our stay and would book it again in the future.
airbnb
AllisonMay 2026
We had a wonderful stay at this home. It was very clean, comfortable, and organized. We love the location and all that Keuka Lake has to offer.
airbnb
BrookeApril 2026
This Finger Lakes cottage was immaculate and beautifully decorated. It had the most gorgeous views and was very clean and comfortable. The host did mention that this property uses a well which results in a sulfuric smell to the water, however, it should be noted that it was a very powerful and pungent smell that radiates throughout the house if you have to take a shower or wash dishes. We live in a rural setting and have a well with bad water, but it is not remotely close to the odor from this well. I wouldn't want a long stay here as I would avoid using the shower (my hair smelled like sulfur all day long... even with a heavy amount of leave-in conditioner and perfume sprayed into it). We also would have appreciated some room darkening blinds in the bedroom. The cabin has beautiful lighting and windows, but we weren't able to sleep after the sun came up due to it being so bright inside.
airbnb
RyanJanuary 2026
Beautiful home very relaxing and nice scenery.
airbnb
MarilynJanuary 2026
Thanks for the lovely weekend in the finger lakes. House was wonderful for everything we needed. Enjoyed exploring the area. We even enjoyed playing Ms Pacman.
airbnb