Manager Review

Finger Lakes Premier Properties in Keuka Park, New York

4.20

This is the local review page for Finger Lakes Premier Properties in Keuka Park, New York. Amongst managers in Keuka Park, Finger Lakes Premier Properties currently ranks 4 of 4 on guest satisfaction. See the top ranked vacation rental managers in Keuka Park, or see homeowner reviews of Finger Lakes Premier Properties on their profile.

Finger Lakes Premier Properties's guest rating in Keuka Park, New York of 4.20 is below average and may adversely impact performance. Some of this can come from specific properties they manage — but where reviews point to manager weaknesses (responsiveness, cleanliness, listing accuracy) that would apply to your home too, they can adversely affect your bookings and the quality of guests you attract. You can see higher-rated managers in Keuka Park.

Recent guest reviews

MatthewAugust 2026
Very private and beautiful location. Quiet and peaceful. Easy access to water with walk in beach. Easy to get in and accurately described 4 bedroom clean cottage with awesome hot tub, outdoor space and grill. Top stairs a little steep for older folk and parking is more like 2.5 spots. Worth the price thanks for the stay
airbnb
PattyJune 2026
Great location and beautiful views, I would highly recommend
airbnb
KendraJune 2026
The house reminded us of a cabin that isn’t used often. The furniture was well used and smelled. The house overall had a musty smell. The carpets were extremely dirty. We couldn’t walk around without our feet or socks turning black. We took our two infants along and their legs and feet were black from walking and crawling around. The kitchen table was very sticky. We tried cleaning it and nothing would help. The dishes we used needed to be washed and rinsed out before using because they were visibly dirty. Two of the beds had bugs in the bottom of the sheets. Two days before we checked in, the company called us saying we couldn’t use the dock because the winter weather had warped it. There were still ways to access the lake, but that was a bummer. We spent the majority of our time outside. The lake is stunning and very relaxing. We will definitely be going back to Keuka, but never to this house.
airbnb
July 2025
Fantastic stay at this quaint cottage! Location was perfect for off the beaten path. Great dock, nice smooth rock beach, amazing sunsets on the patio. Just a tad far from anything useful (just getting back out past the state park takes 10+ min), but stock up on your way in and you wont need to leave. The AC struggled to keep up upstairs during the hottest week of the year, but the lake is pristine and cool. Also, hot tub!
airbnb
June 2025
Beautiful view and cute little cottage! Perfect for our stay to get away and relax!
airbnb