Manager Review

Finger Lakes Premier Properties in Geneva, New York

4.84

This is the local review page for Finger Lakes Premier Properties in Geneva, New York. Amongst managers in Geneva, Finger Lakes Premier Properties currently ranks 2 of 2 on guest satisfaction. See the top ranked vacation rental managers in Geneva, or see homeowner reviews of Finger Lakes Premier Properties on their profile.

Recent guest reviews

AnanyaJune 2026
The house was beautiful and had a private dock right on Lake Seneca. 10 of us rented it out for my bachelorette trip. It was our first time visiting the Finger Lakes and we had a wonderful time. The hosts were responsive and left clear instructions. The only reason I’m giving it 4 stars is because the one of the bathrooms on the bottom floor didn’t have hot water our entire trip. Additionally, there were no cleaning supplies, or hand soap in the kitchen or spare dishrags or spare linens beyond the individual packed towels. The host only provided 2 dishwashing tablets and a small bottle of dish soap meaning that we bought extra cleaning supplies (e.g paper towels, dishwasher tablets, garbage bags) in order to complete the checkout instructions which was mildly annoying. Other than that we had a wonderful stay right on Lake Seneca, the views from the lake were beautiful, peaceful, relaxing and exactly what we were looking for our group! Thank you for having us!
airbnb
AngeloJune 2026
Great place and professional and responsive host!
airbnb
PatriciaMay 2026
We had a great stay at this beautiful lakefront property. It is as shown and described in the photos. The highlight is definitely the location right on the water—especially the picture perfect view right out of the windows near the kitchen. You can’t beat it. This property could definitely use some upgrades, but was perfect for our large group and the gorgeous scenic views. Property management was very responsive and communicative.
airbnb
EstherMay 2026
Relaxing place
airbnb
MerandaMay 2026
We absolutely loved staying here for Mother’s Day. Hoping to visit again!
airbnb