Manager Review

Cooperstown Stay in Fly Creek, New York

4.88

This is the local review page for Cooperstown Stay in Fly Creek, New York. See homeowner reviews of Cooperstown Stay on their profile.

Recent guest reviews

RachelJune 2026
Exceeded expectations! Perfect location for those attending Cooperstown dream park. Easy to get to downtown! Overall amazing experience, hosts were a delight, house was amazing and it had the most perfect lawn for whiffle ball and awesome fire pit!!
airbnb
KatieJune 2026
House is comfortable, owners are friendly, and location is convenient to Dreams Park and Cooperstown. We enjoyed our stay and had everything we needed. I recommend the property to anyone wanting to visit Cooperstown or surrounding areas. The owners are very sweet and answer any questions very quickly.
airbnb
BonnieJune 2026
Enjoyed it.
airbnb
November 2025
We came up for our annual family guys trip. Each year we select a new location to explore. This year was Cooperstown due to the Baseball Hall of Fame, so we needed a place close to the village. This home was perfect for our needs. We each had our own bedrooms, plenty of space where we didn’t feel on top of the other. Ease to get to Cooperstown and surrounding stores. Beautiful property to walk. Easy walk down the path to the Fly Creek Cider Mill. I want to come back in the future and use this home at my home base to explore the Catskills and Adirondack mountains as well as a trip out to Seneca Falls and other areas as this home seems perfectly suited to reach all of those places within a couple hours drive. Also, host was super responsive and polite.
airbnb
October 2025
We had a wonderful stay at the 1825 Farm house! We enjoyed the walking path to Fly Creek Cidery and how close we were to Otesaga Lake and Cooperstown. The house was spacious, clean, and comfortable. Thank you!
airbnb