Manager Review

Finger Lakes Premier Properties in New York

Finger Lakes Premier Properties's guest reviews across New York. See homeowner reviews of Finger Lakes Premier Properties on their profile.

Finger Lakes Premier Properties's guest rating in New York of 4.73 is below average and may adversely impact performance. Some of this can come from specific properties they manage — but where reviews point to manager weaknesses (responsiveness, cleanliness, listing accuracy) that would apply to your home too, they can adversely affect your bookings and the quality of guests you attract. You can see higher-rated managers in New York.

Recent guest reviews

KristinJune 2026Honeoye
We had a siblings weekend here, which was a perfect waterfront getaway. We were able to grill out, have a bonfire and explore many of the surrounding Finger Lakes in the short time that we stayed. The couch pulls out to a comfortable bed, which we used so no one had to sleep on the top bunk. It was a great size for the three of us and we would definitely stay again.
airbnb
GregoryJune 2026Lodi
Great place to stay!
airbnb
KristenJune 2026Dundee
We had the best time staying at Hook Wine & Sinker for a bachelorette trip! The house was beautiful and we were impressed with how clean it was. The description was “inaccurate” because the house was even better than we expected! The listing photos don’t do it justice. Awesome place to stay, we’d love to go back!
airbnb
ScottJune 2026Dundee
We had a great weekend with friends. The house was perfect for four couples. It was clean and had a beautiful view. We did some touring during the day, then enjoyed the evening by the lake. Perfect location!
airbnb
KendrickJune 2026Seneca Falls
The Airbnb and property are absolutely beautiful. We were very pleasantly surprised by how clean the home was upon arrival. The fact that all of the towels were individually wrapped in plastic made it clear that extra attention had been given to cleanliness and guest preparation. One thing I wish had been communicated more clearly before booking was the lack of basic household supplies. We were not aware that we would need to purchase items such as trash bags, coffee filters, zip-top bags, and aluminum foil. Guests should also plan to bring their own shampoo, conditioner, and body soap, as these were not provided. Additionally, only two dishwasher pods were supplied, which was not quite enough for our group of nine and the number of loads we needed to run during our stay. I also wish the check-in and check-out policies were a bit more flexible. The additional $50 charge for each hour of early arrival or late departure felt somewhat restrictive. Overall, the property and home are stu
airbnb

Amongst managers in New York, Finger Lakes Premier Properties currently ranks 11/18 on guest satisfaction. See the top ranked vacation rental managers in New York.