Manager Review

Finger Lakes Premier Properties in New York

Finger Lakes Premier Properties's guest reviews across New York. See homeowner reviews of Finger Lakes Premier Properties on their profile.

Finger Lakes Premier Properties's guest rating in New York of 4.71 is below average and may adversely impact performance. Some of this can come from specific properties they manage — but where reviews point to manager weaknesses (responsiveness, cleanliness, listing accuracy) that would apply to your home too, they can adversely affect your bookings and the quality of guests you attract. You can see higher-rated managers in New York.

Recent guest reviews

TerriMay 2026Seneca Falls
Location was beautiful. Very responsive! Overall a great stay.
airbnb
BethMay 2026Canandaigua
We had an absolutely delightful time at this property, group of around 14 of us, felt very at home and had more than enough room to feel comfortable. The view and backyard was wonderful. The absolute only thing that we were a tad upset about is that the dock wasn’t out like it said it was going to be/how it was in the pictures. But the team was very communicative and responsive and every other note/issue was sorted almost immediately. Would definitely come again! Probably soon!!!
airbnb
JosephMay 2026Penn Yan
The place was beautiful, the lake was really nice. Kayaking out from the dock was super easy and very relaxing. There were lots of great places nearby.
airbnb
DustinMay 2026Hector
What an incredible and beautiful area. Highly recommend, peaceful with views and close distance to all. Waking up and being feet from the lake was perfect. The neighbors and other visitors were extremely friendly and always said hello. I would gladly stay here again.
airbnb
SusanMay 2026Branchport
This property stood out to us because it fit the amount of people we were hosting as well as having enough onsite parking. We were a group of 12 with varying arrival times. Other properties only allowed a couple of onsite parking spots then over flow at an alternative site. We had plenty of parking here. Hanging out on the deck or at the dining room table with our morning coffee was a highlight. We particularly enjoyed the huge fish that jumped out of the water on occasion and the pair of herons that would meander by! The evening fire out on the lawn and soaks in the hot tub, led to great conversation and many laughs! The location on Keuka Lake for our day of winery touring worked out very well. Also, not too far for dinner in Geneva and a couple of stops at wineries on Seneca Lake. We had a delightful weekend and would recommend the property to others looking for a relaxing stay.
airbnb

Amongst managers in New York, Finger Lakes Premier Properties currently ranks 10/15 on guest satisfaction. See the top ranked vacation rental managers in New York.