Manager Review

Vacasa in Dundee, New York

4.47

This is the local review page for Vacasa in Dundee, New York. Amongst managers in Dundee, Vacasa currently ranks 3 of 3 on guest satisfaction. See the top ranked vacation rental managers in Dundee, or see homeowner reviews of Vacasa on their profile.

Vacasa's guest rating in Dundee, New York of 4.47 is below average and may adversely impact performance. Some of this can come from specific properties they manage — but where reviews point to manager weaknesses (responsiveness, cleanliness, listing accuracy) that would apply to your home too, they can adversely affect your bookings and the quality of guests you attract. You can see higher-rated managers in Dundee.

Recent guest reviews

TorreyJune 2026
We will stay here again if it is available for our next trip to the Finger Lakes!
airbnb
GretaJune 2026
My friends and I enjoyed a long weekend at this Airbnb. The location is beautiful and the house is right on the water with easy lake access. We were able to enjoy camp fires down by the dock and the hot tub. Overall, we liked the location and the house; we would book again. However, we want to be upfront about some aspects of this listing that are not shown nor mentioned. The bathroom doors have glass windows that are clear enough to see in the bathroom with the doors closed. We had to put a blanket up to ensure privacy. The top floor bathroom also only has a tub; it is not a shower. The tub’s cold water does not work. The bottom floor has the only shower. The bottom floor bedroom is only able to be located by walking through the bathroom.
airbnb
DarrenJune 2026
Great place, outstanding views, and dog friendly! Would recommend without reservations.
airbnb
MattJune 2026
we enjoyed our stay ar your cute little cottage. There was plenty room for our family and friends. We enjoyed our morning coffee on the outside porch. Beautiful views
airbnb
LeannMay 2026
Let me start by saying I have grown up on the water. My parents and grandparents both, had cottages on lakes, when I was growing up and I have spent many years camping and being on the lakes. This property was grossly misrepresented. It is not a house nor a cottage. It was a cabin. I have no problem with a cabin but had I read that it was a cabin, we would not have rented. I am attaching more pictures to support our issues and complaints. Smaller issues: 1. The house was difficult to find as it does not show up on Google or Apple Maps. Additionally, there is NO address number at the top of the driveway! 2. The water dispenser started leaking the second we turned it on. 3. I have no issues with "rustic" and "charming" but this property was neither. Perhaps it was 50 years ago, but the furniture inside and out were obviously purchased in the 1980's and had not been updated or replaced since then. The photos on Airbnb were NOT recent photos and misrepresented the state of the prope
airbnb