Manager Review

Cooperstown Stay in New York

Cooperstown Stay's guest reviews across New York. See homeowner reviews of Cooperstown Stay on their profile.

Recent guest reviews

KristineMay 2026Laurens
Great stay!
airbnb
RiverMay 2026Oneonta
Great place- they just ask for an additional $500 deposit prior to stay on top of the insurance that Airbnb already provides them- first time having an additional charge on top of the reservation charge
airbnb
Janine CarlaMay 2026Maryland
Great choice to stay on Goodyear Lake for easy access to Oneonta, Cooperstown and a short 1 hour drive to Albany! Relaxing view of the lake, access to fishing and host was very responsive. Would stay here again.
airbnb
DebMay 2026Oneonta
Great place!
airbnb
LaraMay 2026Oneonta
Thank you so much for the perfect home away from home to celebrate my daughter's college graduation with family. There was enough room for 6 adults to fit comfortably. Carl responded almost immediately to all my requests. The kitchen was stocked with everything needed for cooking. Outside deck area had nice table w/ umbrella and chairs, and a grill. There are extra chairs, coolers, etc. available. Note that this home is on a busy street and the steps are steep for if you have young children or senior travelers.
airbnb

Amongst managers in New York, Cooperstown Stay currently ranks 5/15 on guest satisfaction. See the top ranked vacation rental managers in New York.