Manager Review

Cooperstown Stay in New York

Cooperstown Stay's guest reviews across New York. See homeowner reviews of Cooperstown Stay on their profile.

Recent guest reviews

AnneJune 2026Milford
Host was very kind and flexible. Responsive to all of our needs and accommodated us in every way possible. Location was perfect for Dreamspark.
airbnb
Katharine BishopJune 2026Cooperstown
We absolutely loved staying here! The most beautiful views and communication was excellent when we had questions. The place was so clean and we really enjoyed our time here! Thank you and highly recommend!
airbnb
MadyJune 2026Cooperstown
Casa Vista really did have a beautiful view, especially in the early morning. We were skeptical after reading a review about an odor from the water, but we were pleasantly surprised with this home. No issues at all with the water. Actually, the water is clearly treated and feels soft on the skin after a shower. The only critique was the size of the home feeling slightly small for a family of 4, and with 1 bathroom, but we still enjoyed our stay very much. We were sad to leave. If we return to the area, we would consider staying here again.
airbnb
TiffanyJune 2026Cooperstown
Location was great! I missed in the listing that the owners lived on site ( maybe I overlooked ) Completely caught off guard when the owners were in the driveway showing us where to park. Not a bad experience .. just something new for us. The family were all great everyone was super friendly. Parking next to owners cars on other side of house and walking around there entire house was just different. I was under the impression if I can hear the owners and family/ kids they can also hear us which was a little uncomfortable but not horrible Place was clean, had everything we needed but the bed was horrible! It felt like it had plywood under it and was honestly the worst bed I’ve ever layed on. I attempted the couch one night bc it was that bad ! Overall good experience with a great location very close to dream park.
airbnb
LauraJune 2026Mount Vision
We really enjoyed our stay. Was convenient but tucked away. Easy to get to Cooperstown. My only complaints are the bathroom downstairs. The water pressure was not great and the pillows on the beds weren’t the most comfortable, but it was still a nice stay. They could use some extra pillows and blankets in the house for sure.
airbnb

Amongst managers in New York, Cooperstown Stay currently ranks 6/18 on guest satisfaction. See the top ranked vacation rental managers in New York.