Manager Review

Finger Lakes Premier Properties in Cayuga, New York

4.43

This is the local review page for Finger Lakes Premier Properties in Cayuga, New York. Amongst managers in Cayuga, Finger Lakes Premier Properties currently ranks 2 of 2 on guest satisfaction. See the top ranked vacation rental managers in Cayuga, or see homeowner reviews of Finger Lakes Premier Properties on their profile.

Finger Lakes Premier Properties's guest rating in Cayuga, New York of 4.43 is below average and may adversely impact performance. Some of this can come from specific properties they manage — but where reviews point to manager weaknesses (responsiveness, cleanliness, listing accuracy) that would apply to your home too, they can adversely affect your bookings and the quality of guests you attract. You can see higher-rated managers in Cayuga.

Recent guest reviews

GerardMay 2026
Beautiful and quiet
airbnb
October 2025
Beautiful quiet place, railroad Bridge very tight squeeze good thing we didn't bring the truck. It needs to be addressed when renting.
airbnb
September 2025
We had a very beautiful stay at this place. There was plenty of kayaks and swimming accessories to use in the basement. The house itself was beautiful. We did find the drive under the train tracks to be a bit of a tight squeeze in an SUV, and not well lit at night. There also wasn’t a full description of where to put the trash so we reached out to the host. Within several hours, someone did get back to us and helped us find a place to put the trash but it was a bit confusing. The kitchen was also lacking basic kitchen accessories, like oil, salt, pepper. Overall, we had a lovely stay and would recommend.
airbnb
August 2025
Overall the lake cottage was a cute get away on the lake, on a very private and quiet road. However our truck could not fit through the tunnel(the only road to the house). If you stay bring a small car. Bring coffee and seasonings. I appreciate it being pet friendly however there was an excessive amount of pet hair and dust under the beds, couches and cabinets. We enjoyed the beautiful sunsets.
airbnb
July 2025
This house does not have a dishwasher and not adequate toiletries for an entire week stay. No paper towels, not enough toilet paper and no dish soap to wash dishes by hand. For the money I would not recommend this place. Bigger homes in the area for a lot less money.
airbnb