Manager Review

Finger Lakes Premier Properties reviews in Canandaigua, New York

Finger Lakes Premier Properties holds a 4.63 guest rating in Canandaigua, New York, computed from 90 Airbnb guest reviews across the vacation rentals they manage there. That ranks them 2 of 2 managers in the market on guest satisfaction. See the top ranked vacation rental managers in Canandaigua, or homeowner reviews of Finger Lakes Premier Properties on their profile.

Finger Lakes Premier Properties's guest rating in Canandaigua, New York of 4.63 is below average and may adversely impact performance. Some of this can come from specific properties they manage — but where reviews point to manager weaknesses (responsiveness, cleanliness, listing accuracy) that would apply to your home too, they can adversely affect your bookings and the quality of guests you attract. You can see higher-rated managers in Canandaigua.

Recent guest reviews in Canandaigua

MikeOctober 2026
“Squeaky clean place with beautiful view. The entrance is up a big flight of stairs. If you arrive after dark, it can be tricky - and slippery with deck stairs. Overall poorly lit except big windows to the lake in the living room. The place seemed a bit sterile, lacking cozy elements like soap, plush towels and coffee. All the closets and garage are locked, so there was not a lot of storage. The place seemed a bit unfinished, so some of this may change. However we would stay there again to be in such a breathtaking location.”
airbnb
GaryOctober 2026
“This property is right on the lake and has a great view of the sunset each nice. That was the main draw for us and it delivered! It's a quick drive to the main street with several restaurants and shops. The house rules that are sent over warn you about potential bugs and spiderwebs and they weren't kidding! There were several webs in and out of the house. This is more of a vacation rental than a quick couple of nights type place. The kitchen had NOTHING in terms in salt, pepper, cooking oil, or anything of that nature. Not a big deal if you're there for a couple weeks and you stock up, but not ideal for a night or two and you don't want to stock a kitchen to do basic cooking. Between that and the full list of chores to do before check-out, we definitely spent a little more time and money to do some basic parts of an airbnb stay. Overall a good experience and would visit again for a longer stretch knowing what I know now.”
airbnb
AaronSeptember 2026
“We really enjoyed our stay. The property and house were lovely. The views were picturesque and trails around the property were quite well kept. A few things that kept it from being a 5 star stay. The smaller critiques were that while the property was beautiful we wish the property lines were better marked to ensure we weren’t wandering onto another property from the trails. Additionally the king mattress was not very comfortable. The most significant issue is that we needed to do remote work while there and the WiFi was not suitable for basic tasks like connecting to a server or video conferencing. We ran speed tests and the connection was topping out at 8-10 mbps, so we had to rely on our own hotspot to work remotely. We greatly appreciated our time and think with some tweaks anyone would love to stay here!”
airbnb
StevenAugust 2026
“Beautiful, peaceful location. Lots of space for our family to allow for privacy and group gatherings. It was wonderful that kayaks, paddle boards, lifejackets, tennis rackets and balls, and pickle ball rackets and balls were provided. We miss seeing the lake daily now that we are home.”
airbnb
GillianJuly 2026
“Harmony Hills is a beautiful property! We stayed 3 nights and we didn't have time to do everything the property offered (bon fire by the pond, exploring the woods...). Not pictured/mentioned in the listing is a hot tub and basement with extra TV! Wonderful stay. The only negative was a broken spring in the king mattress - mentioned in a previous review from Nov 2025. Disappointing that this wasn't remedied in the months since.”
airbnb