Manager Review

Silver Gate Lodging in Silver Gate, Montana

4.73

This is the local review page for Silver Gate Lodging in Silver Gate, Montana. See homeowner reviews of Silver Gate Lodging on their profile.

Silver Gate Lodging's guest rating in Silver Gate, Montana of 4.73 is below average and may adversely impact performance. Some of this can come from specific properties they manage — but where reviews point to manager weaknesses (responsiveness, cleanliness, listing accuracy) that would apply to your home too, they can adversely affect your bookings and the quality of guests you attract. You can see higher-rated managers in Silver Gate.

Recent guest reviews

RyanAugust 2026
This was a really fun cabin tucked privately on the other side of Soda Butte. It is more rustic feeling but that’s exactly what we were looking for and what we expected. There’s a kitchen with an oven and stove top, which is nice for families and it’s a short walk down to the creek where we saw kids fishing. Bed was comfy and slept great with the cool mountain air coming in the window. Would stay here again!
airbnb
AdriannAugust 2026
Easy check in and stay for passing through silver gate.
airbnb
BethAugust 2026
Super comfy bed!
airbnb
PaigeAugust 2026
Great place to stay in Cooke City! Of note, there is no wifi or AC in the cabins. Not a problem for us though. There was a fan that helped to cool temps down at night.
airbnb
MarielenaJuly 2026
Silver Gate Lodge is conveniently located near Yellowstone NE gate. We arrived after 9pm and couldn't find general store at first but other locals directed us to it. Once we found it the keys with a map were on a magnet outside the general store making it very easy to find our cabin. We wished the cabin had a microwave but were able to reheat leftovers on the stove in a pot which worked perfectly well. Plenty of bowls, cups and utensils and a table to enjoy dinner at. We were only there for one night from from 10pm-4am so didn't get to enjoy the outdoor seating area with the fire pit. Next time! We also appreciate that they rent scopes, which we will take advantage of next time. There is also a cute little coffee truck next to the general store which we will also try next time!
airbnb