Manager Review

Stay Montana in Livingston, Montana

4.76

This is the local review page for Stay Montana in Livingston, Montana. Amongst managers in Livingston, Stay Montana currently ranks 3 of 3 on guest satisfaction. See the top ranked vacation rental managers in Livingston, or see homeowner reviews of Stay Montana on their profile.

Stay Montana's guest rating in Livingston, Montana of 4.76 is below average and may adversely impact performance. Some of this can come from specific properties they manage — but where reviews point to manager weaknesses (responsiveness, cleanliness, listing accuracy) that would apply to your home too, they can adversely affect your bookings and the quality of guests you attract. You can see higher-rated managers in Livingston.

Recent guest reviews

BradAugust 2026
My wife and I rented "Yellowstone River Retreat" from Stay Montana via Airbnb. The unit was in an unclean, unacceptable condition on arrival (dirty bedding, dirty bathroom with dirty towels on floor and other dirty surfaces). Stay Montana acknowledged the issue and agreed to a full refund, but conditioned that refund on us signing a "Guest Resolution Agreement" with a non-disparagement clause prohibiting my wife or I from leaving a negative review. I declined to sign, and Stay Montana confirmed in writing they will not refund me without my signature. I also submitted a claim directly to Airbnb for the unclean/inaccurate listing, which Airbnb was able to partially resolve leaving me with a partial refund. Airbnb support staff was quick and understanding about this matter.
airbnb
August 2025
The home was very comfortable and clean! Communication with the host was fantastic as they immediately got back to us when we had a small issue upon arrival. The only reason I gave this place 4-stars for location is because the dirt road leading to the house was quite bumpy and dusty - something us city slickers weren't prepared for. Overall our stay was great and we all agreed we would stay here again!
airbnb
August 2025
This was a great stay! A few things I wish we’d known: 1. It’s on a very long, unkept, dirt road. Even in a full size SUV there were tough spots; it’s so rough that it rattled our front sensors out. 2. Trash removal is almost an hour round trip and it’s a required round trip due to a vehicle tag. 3. This is clearly a new property and as a result we ran into a couple hiccups with access. For now, just insist on the code for the PADLOCK, not just the electric lock on the door. These weren’t dealbreakers, just things I would like to have prepared for. They did a GREAT job handling these challenges! They have a very thorough and usable digital system for contact, info and instructions. Lastly, I must say, that this was such a treat. The stillness and quiet were just what our busy souls needed. The interior was well appointed, and very comfortable. We would go back; and we’d consider Stay Montana first and always!! Thank you!
airbnb
July 2025
Clean and well appointed place. Had questions but they answered quickly no matter that hour.
airbnb
July 2025
Absolutely stunning location. Great location for day trips into Yellowstone and still close enough to Livingston for some delicious dinners
airbnb