Manager Review

Mitten Group Property Management in Shelby, Michigan

4.43

This is the local review page for Mitten Group Property Management in Shelby, Michigan. Amongst managers in Shelby, Mitten Group Property Management currently ranks 3 of 3 on guest satisfaction. See the top ranked vacation rental managers in Shelby, or see homeowner reviews of Mitten Group Property Management on their profile.

Mitten Group Property Management's guest rating in Shelby, Michigan of 4.43 is below average and may adversely impact performance. Some of this can come from specific properties they manage — but where reviews point to manager weaknesses (responsiveness, cleanliness, listing accuracy) that would apply to your home too, they can adversely affect your bookings and the quality of guests you attract. You can see higher-rated managers in Shelby.

Recent guest reviews

Rebecca Kathlyn HauwAugust 2026
“The number of bedrooms and bathrooms was perfect for our large family with plenty of space for everyone, ranging from newborn to 70 years old. The double dishwasher and second fridge were really nice to have as well! Anytime there was an issue, the team responded quickly.”
airbnb
JessicaJune 2026
“Nice place for a large group. Good bedrooms. Needs some touchup, but it was fine.”
airbnb
IsisJune 2026
“Really nice play to say, felt homely”
airbnb
JohnJune 2026
“Great location. Plenty of room for our 6 and could easily accommodate 3 or 4 more. They could use a new grill and propane. The grill was a mess and there was no propane so make sure you are prepared for that. Overall, a great place to hang out with a group.”
airbnb
BreonaMay 2026
“Overall, we had a great stay and the house comfortably accommodated all 13 of us. It was especially nice that everyone had their own bathroom, and the proximity to the beach was definitely a huge plus. That said, it felt like the home wasn’t fully stocked for a group our size. There were no dish towels provided in the kitchen, only one roll of paper towels, and just 3 dishwasher pods for our 4 night stay. We also noticed several dead bugs in multiple rooms when we first checked in. One other downside was the lack of a common seating area for a large group. We would have loved a space where everyone could relax but the living room seating only accommodated about six people comfortably. Overall, the space and location were great, but a few small improvements with cleanliness, supplies, and common-area seating would make the experience even better.”
airbnb