Manager Review

Freshwater Vacation Rentals in New Buffalo, Michigan

4.58

This is the local review page for Freshwater Vacation Rentals in New Buffalo, Michigan. Amongst managers in New Buffalo, Freshwater Vacation Rentals currently ranks 9 of 9 on guest satisfaction. See the top ranked vacation rental managers in New Buffalo, or see homeowner reviews of Freshwater Vacation Rentals on their profile.

Freshwater Vacation Rentals's guest rating in New Buffalo, Michigan of 4.58 is below average and may adversely impact performance. Some of this can come from specific properties they manage — but where reviews point to manager weaknesses (responsiveness, cleanliness, listing accuracy) that would apply to your home too, they can adversely affect your bookings and the quality of guests you attract. You can see higher-rated managers in New Buffalo.

Recent guest reviews

MarinaAugust 2026
“The Whit was an awesome house to stay in! Best location ever which was walkable to so many downtown places. Pool and hot tub area were so much fun for the kids. Beds were a little soft but comfy for most of us. Lots of pillows which I appreciate! Enough towels and paper products for everyone. Fun games and puzzles for the kids! Loved our stay and will definitely be back!”
airbnb
MarekAugust 2026
“The best parts of this place is the location and the pool/hot tub combo. The rest of the house is underwhelming, especially for the steep premium paid. The house is in need of some major maintenance and upkeep. For example, there are rooms where the door paint and wall paint is chipping. The umbrella on the patio is broken. There’s weeds growing out of the pool patio. Also, during our stay, we had water in the basement and nobody came out. There is construction next-door, which doesn’t give a nice view and early morning noise.”
airbnb
JeffJuly 2026
“great property! would definitely stay there again. Easily accommodates very large groups.”
airbnb
AmandaJuly 2026
“The house was beautiful! Location was PERFECT! We had 5 adults and 3 kids with us during the hottest week of 2026 and we had a blast! The only thing I would recommend is the cleaner doing a deep clean of the house! We will most definitely be back!!”
airbnb
YumiJune 2026
“Perfect rental 10/10. Super quiet neighborhood. The pool and hot tub were wonderful. The host were incredibly responsive when we had a couple of quick questions. Plenty of room for all of our kids to stretch out and not be on top of each other. Walkable within 5 to 10 minutes to everything in town.”
airbnb