Manager Review

Plushy in Newton, Massachusetts

4.72

This is the local review page for Plushy in Newton, Massachusetts. Amongst managers in Newton, Plushy currently ranks 1 of 3 on guest satisfaction. See the top ranked vacation rental managers in Newton, or see homeowner reviews of Plushy on their profile.

Plushy's guest rating in Newton, Massachusetts of 4.72 is below average and may adversely impact performance. Some of this can come from specific properties they manage — but where reviews point to manager weaknesses (responsiveness, cleanliness, listing accuracy) that would apply to your home too, they can adversely affect your bookings and the quality of guests you attract. You can see higher-rated managers in Newton.

Recent guest reviews

StevenMay 2026
Place is OK. It was very clean. It is an older place so the floors all squeak loudly. It's not possible to get up to the bathroom without waking everyone else up. My real problem with the place has to do with the ridig thermostat rules. To whit: You are LOCKED OUT of the thermostat between May and October. Our May stay included a very cool day/night. My 90 year old mother was cold and there were no blankets in the place. I had to call for one which they delivered the next day (too late). There is also not a book, magazine, board game, local brochures/guides of any kind. This place is clearly meant to be the bare minimum to maximize profit. The phone/text help is canned responses often ignoring the question posed. I will avoid Plushy's offerings in the future.
airbnb
SarahFebruary 2026
King of the AirBnBs ♥️ the best of the best. A true home, amazingly responsive host and stellar cleanliness. If hotel quality clean and fresh linens are important to you, look no further. Plushy should teach the course on how to create a homestay that exudes excellence, quality and warmth. I’ll stay here every time.
airbnb
November 2025
The place was clean and the neighborhood was very nice. We never understood what the dehumidifiers were doing and how they were working. Actually they were too loud and we never used them.
airbnb
October 2025
We had a lovely stay! The accommodations were clean and cozy. The neighborhood was nice as well, and close to restaurants and train stations. We would definitely stay again. Thanks for having us!
airbnb
September 2025
Needs clearer directions for air conditioning use and clarity between dehumidifier and air conditioning unit. Also, the host is very responsive but the responses can be hard to understand at times as if they were generated by chat GPT.
airbnb