Manager Review

The Island Agency in Stonington, Maine

4.79

This is the local review page for The Island Agency in Stonington, Maine. See homeowner reviews of The Island Agency on their profile.

The Island Agency's guest rating in Stonington, Maine of 4.79 is below average and may adversely impact performance. Some of this can come from specific properties they manage — but where reviews point to manager weaknesses (responsiveness, cleanliness, listing accuracy) that would apply to your home too, they can adversely affect your bookings and the quality of guests you attract. You can see higher-rated managers in Stonington.

Recent guest reviews

October 2025
We had a family trip up with our family and both sets of grandparents. The area was gorgeous, and we really enjoyed this property.
airbnb
October 2025
We loved Aquarian Adjourn! The location was truly incredible, the windows and deck overlooking Stonington's harbor so unique, the house itself had everything we needed and fit us well and The Island Agency went out of their way to accommodate us. We have a bunch of kids and some people with kids might be nervous about the rocky shoreline but we loved it and our kids truly had a blast, catching crabs everyday and searching around on the rocks for treasures. We brought a canoe and tied it up right by the house going for lots of exploring trips to watch the lobsterboats or visit some of the nearby uninhabited islands. FYI at low tide there is only mud surrounding the house but this was fine with us, we loved watching the shifting tides and seeing the blue herons fishing around at low tide. There are also two raccoons that live under one of the decks, that was part of the experience for our kids too! Don't leave out any bait or food though or they will surely swipe it :)
airbnb
October 2025
The little cabin Camprene is a very cute rustic cabin with fantastic views from the picture windows and the deck. I stay a month and enjoyed every day. If you want fantastic views and close to restaurants and town the cabin is perfect. If you are looking for an authentic rustic cabin this is it. The Island Agency was extremely helpful and friendly. I locked myself out late one evening and two of the ladies came very quickly to let us in. I would hesitate to rent anything they offer.
airbnb
September 2025
Hands down, this has been my favorite AirBnB we've stayed at. We went with another family and had 3 adults and 8 kids, ranging from 2-12. They had so much to explore and so many places to be in the house that it didn't feel like we even needed to leave to have our "Maine" experience. The house was wonderfully appointed, having everything we needed. Plenty to cook with, plenty of puzzles, lots of seating, a great number of bathrooms. Just couldn't have been more pleased. The pictures don't do the home justice and the property is sprawling and scenic. All of us left wanting to plan another return trip!
airbnb
September 2025
We were looking for a place to relax and enjoy the view of the water and the lobster boats and this was an absolute perfect location. We sat on the deck every morning and evening and just could not get over the quiet beauty. The house was beautiful inside and out. Stonington is a lovely town and we would love to return again someday.
airbnb