Manager Review

MTM Premier Property Management in Michigan City, Indiana

4.77

This is the local review page for MTM Premier Property Management in Michigan City, Indiana. Amongst managers in Michigan City, MTM Premier Property Management currently ranks 4 of 4 on guest satisfaction. See the top ranked vacation rental managers in Michigan City, or see homeowner reviews of MTM Premier Property Management on their profile.

MTM Premier Property Management's guest rating in Michigan City, Indiana of 4.77 is below average and may adversely impact performance. Some of this can come from specific properties they manage β€” but where reviews point to manager weaknesses (responsiveness, cleanliness, listing accuracy) that would apply to your home too, they can adversely affect your bookings and the quality of guests you attract. You can see higher-rated managers in Michigan City.

Recent guest reviews

LesleyJune 2026
β€œThis place was so peaceful we loved the patio and sunroom the fire place was amazing”
airbnb
LukeJune 2026
β€œOur time here was pretty good. We enjoyed the hot tub the most. One of the better looking houses in an otherwise fairly rundown neighborhood. We noticed an odd smell when we arrived which seemed to fade after an hour or two of the windows being open. The downstairs sleeping accommodations were very noisy. We heard every creaky floorboard and rush of water through the pipes that happened throughout the night. Overall, an adequate housing option, not super far driving distance from the beach.”
airbnb
TaraJune 2026
β€œWe enjoyed our stay! Quick walk < 0.5 mile to the beach. Backyard was perfect. Kitchen with everything you need. And loved the fans in the bedrooms. We would all stay here again!”
airbnb
MargieJune 2026
β€œWe used and thoroughly enjoyed all of the amenities like 2 nice bikes, and wagons to pull babies, beach chairs and umbrellas, the kiddy pool, the gas fireplace on the deck along with the wood-burning one, and the covered picnic table on the deck and two rocking chairs on the front deck. It all worked out beautifully for our three couples and two 1 yr olds.”
airbnb
MakaylaJune 2026
β€œMy family and I loved our experience it was a lot of fun and we appreciated the provided amenities especially kitchen utensils. we were very impressed with how well kept and clean the hot tub was! We would definitely book again. The only tricky part was when we arrived on the map the pin is wrong and says the house is up the hill and off to the left. Which it’s not so for future guests it would be a good key to let them know when following GPS πŸ˜‚ the area is like a horseshoe and where it pins you have to follow the road and follow right down the drive way and the house will be on the right hand side near the stop sign- exit :)”
airbnb