Manager Review

MTM Premier Property Management reviews in Michigan City, Indiana

4.77

MTM Premier Property Management holds a 4.77 guest rating in Michigan City, Indiana, computed from 577 Airbnb guest reviews across the vacation rentals they manage there. That ranks them 4 of 6 managers in the market on guest satisfaction. See the top ranked vacation rental managers in Michigan City, or homeowner reviews of MTM Premier Property Management on their profile.

MTM Premier Property Management's guest rating in Michigan City, Indiana of 4.77 is below average and may adversely impact performance. Some of this can come from specific properties they manage — but where reviews point to manager weaknesses (responsiveness, cleanliness, listing accuracy) that would apply to your home too, they can adversely affect your bookings and the quality of guests you attract. You can see higher-rated managers in Michigan City.

Recent guest reviews in Michigan City

MichaelSeptember 2026
“It's a nice looking place. Nice beds. What was odd, is there weren't any dishwasher pods, no additional rolls of paper towel, and limited toilet paper. So we had to buy all three. For what we paid, we were surprised at these limitations. After you complete your reservation through Airbnb, you have to fill out additional information for them and include a copy of your driver's license. Didn't feel good about that. You have to message the host to get details on how to get into the property. We waited about 10 minutes which created some uncertainty. Normally, the information is sent via email. It seems the hottub photo was AI enhanced. It would have been nice to have the little table next to the hottub in the photo as there's no space to place some waters like in the photo. When you check out. You have to put the garbage in the can in the alley. Truly, if you had a photo of the backyard, you could not find this gate which we didn't. It just looks like a fence.”
airbnb
CallieSeptember 2026
“House was close to a lot of activities, restaurants and the beach.”
airbnb
JenniferSeptember 2026
“Nice, large house and very clean and bright. Hard to find due to Google Maps taking you to the wrong location. Host very slow to respond to inquires. Nice outside area to hang out. Comfortable beds and pillows. Right down the street from a public beach and park.”
airbnb
AngieSeptember 2026
“Place was nice. We enjoyed our stay.”
airbnb
JimAugust 2026
“It’s a lovely place. The living room is a little too dark for us, but the rest of the house was nice.”
airbnb