Manager Review

Rental Advisor reviews in Idaho

4.66

Rental Advisor's guest reviews across Idaho. See homeowner reviews of Rental Advisor on their profile.

Rental Advisor's guest rating in Idaho of 4.66 is below average and may adversely impact performance. Some of this can come from specific properties they manage — but where reviews point to manager weaknesses (responsiveness, cleanliness, listing accuracy) that would apply to your home too, they can adversely affect your bookings and the quality of guests you attract. You can see higher-rated managers in Idaho.

Recent guest reviews

TabatheOctober 2026Driggs
“We genuinely enjoyed our week at this beautiful property. The home was comfortable, well-appointed, and a wonderful setting for our group of six. Unfortunately, our experience after checkout was disappointing. Despite carefully following the house rules and going beyond the checkout instructions to leave the home in excellent condition, we received an unexpected $160 additional cleaning request involving linens and blankets provided for guest use. Airbnb ultimately resolved the dispute in our favor. After 10 years and 14 Airbnb stays without an issue, this was surprising and stressful. It’s unfortunate because the property itself was lovely, and we truly enjoyed our time there.”
airbnb
AaronOctober 2026Driggs
“Great place for to relax away from the hustle and bustle. Nice and new but could have been a little cleaner.”
airbnb
HeatherSeptember 2026Tetonia
“Entrance code was wrong at arrival and we had to wait to get access, dirty dishes in cabinets, bugs matted to bed linens on beds, master shower had slow drain, fire alarm went off in master bedroom, empty propanes in fire pit & grill, not enough towels for guests allotted for property, dryer left lint all over our clothes from 2-3 inch lint left in appliance. Asking guests to strip beds down to start loads for bed linens but not properly checking the beds for your guests and we find out ourselves that bed linens are dirty with bugs and our daughter getting bit is absolutely ridiculous. If you have any maintenance issues, be aware that you may find a maintenance worker in the home that will just let himself in with no warning and no communication prior. This was where we chose to stay for our destination wedding & I immediately regret it 100% & do not recommend. Poor upkeep of the property.”
airbnb
HunterSeptember 2026Tetonia
“Good location”
airbnb
AamirSeptember 2026Island Park
“Unfair extra money was charged”
airbnb

Amongst managers in Idaho, Rental Advisor currently ranks 28/30 on guest satisfaction. See the top ranked vacation rental managers in Idaho.