Island Park Reservations reviews in Island Park, Idaho

“We had a really nice stay! The space is a studio layout with a line of beds, which worked well for us as a small family and would be great for a small group of friends. It’s very calm and private, tucked between the trees, and we loved the garage space to BBQ and chill at night. Stargazing was amazing — stars were so bright! Kitchen was fully equipped and perfect for cooking after a long day. We skipped the inns because we needed a kitchen. It’s only 1 bathroom, so an extra powder room would help. Wish there was coffee to start the day, as grocers are 15 mins away. Washer didn’t work for us ,no holder for the pod. It’s about 1.5 hrs to Yellowstone and felt a bit pricey for the distance, but it’s a good central base to cover West Yellowstone to Lamar one day and to the Geysers the next. Overall great for a few days. Thanks to the hosts for quick responses!”

“We found this small, eclectic property. It was cute and some might say whimsical. Not everyone’s cup of tea but some would enjoy it. The photos portray a much bigger space than we experienced. Where they lost us is a cleanliness. The bedrooms up stairs had ceiling fans with many months of dirt. We hesitated to turn them on for fear of the likely dust storm that would follow. My wife and daughter stood on the beds cleaning them so we could use them. In the master, my wife tried to plug in pone of the lamps on the night stand and got a shock. Not a surprise but an actual electric shock complete with sparks due to a damaged wires on the plug . Quite a dangerous moment. Next day, I pulled a sauce pan from the cabinet and found two live earwigs in the pan. Day after that I found more on the counter. The small whimsey was ok; albeit not a favorite. That lack of safety and cleanliness is unacceptable. This is allegedly a super host. That status clearly needs serious review.”

“Would strongly recommend against a staying here. Multiple lights were broken in the home and when we reached out to the host about getting them fixed, we had to ask four times and wait four days until they came to check on the property. They came to check when we were not home and both didn’t replace any lights and left the house unlocked with all of our valuables inside. We informed them about this and they ignored us. They also advertise this as a four bed house but there are only three beds (there is an additional mattress which is not very comfortable so that someone can sleep on the floor). You will never communicate with an actual person but rather an anonymous employee of a large holding company who will be very slow to respond to you.”

“It was a beautiful place to stay! However, we paid a lot for multiple things to not be working. They said they would bring a working microwave and didn’t which affected our stay. The WiFi had a lot of problems too. Extensive check out/cleaning instructions with lack of direction for where to put garbage”

“The stay isn’t worth of what we paid for, very expensive. The kitchen isn’t well maintained simple things like knife/blender weren’t working. Microwave has broken buttons. Pans and pots are very old which has coating gone which is harmful to cook food in. Bathroom flush is very weak and bathroom water smells bad. Living room furniture is very old and dirty and needs upgrade. The wooden walkway needs maintenance as one of us got hurt because of a loose plank. The house makes weird noises at night which led to poor sleep. The outside patio needs maintenance and isn’t well maintained we didn’t get to use it even once.”